Original Reassessment Ground Failed? Supreme Court Says Other Issues Can't Save It
The section 148 notice named one reason: you failed to withhold tax on remittances to the overseas parent, so the expense must be disallowed under section 40(a)(i). Years later, the ITAT holds you were never an assessee-in-default under section 201. Can the Assessing Officer keep the reassessment alive on some other issue discovered along the way?
On 7 October 2026 the Supreme Court answered that question for LG Electronics India. Here is what the order actually held, where it stops short of a blanket rule, and how to use it on a live file.
Quick answer: In Principal Officer, LG Electronics India Pvt. Ltd. v. ACIT, Noida (C.A. Nos. 18067/2017, 18068/2017 and 18281/2017, 7 October 2026), a Bench of Justice J.B. Pardiwala and Justice K. Vinod Chandran held reassessment for AYs 2006-07 to 2008-09 unenforceable. The section 148 notices were confined to an alleged TDS default and consequential section 40(a)(i) disallowance. Parallel section 201 proceedings ended with the ITAT holding there was no tax on LG Korea and no section 195 duty. Once that foundational ground failed, other grounds could not save the reassessment. Under the 2025 Act the escaping-income framework sits in sections 279 and 280.

Contents
What did the Supreme Court hold on 7 October 2026?
The assessee had challenged section 147/148 notices before the High Court, which refused to interfere. The Supreme Court allowed the civil appeals.
The material findings, taken from the signed Non-Reportable order, are:
Notices confined to one theme. Reassessment for AYs 2006-07, 2007-08 and 2008-09 alleged that LG Electronics Korea and associated enterprises had a permanent establishment in India, so remittances attracted TDS and failure brought section 40(a)(i) disallowance. Notice dates: 28.03.2013, 21.03.2014 and 31.03.2015.
Survey and parallel tracks. A section 133A survey fed the proceedings. Parallel section 201 proceedings and assessments against the Korean company were also in play.
ITAT on section 201. The Tribunal held there was no tax liability on LG Korea, hence no withholding obligation under section 195, and the Indian company was not an 'assessee-in-default' under section 201.
No remand needed. If section 201 does not stick, section 40(a)(i) cannot survive. The Court saw no need to send the matter back to the Assessing Officer.
Other grounds rejected. The Additional Solicitor General suggested other grounds might have been used in the reassessment. The Court declined that submission because the notice itself was only on the section 201 / 40(a)(i) default.
Closure direction. The assessee is to produce the Supreme Court decision and the ITAT section 201 order before the Assessing Officer, who shall close the reassessment as unenforceable.
The decisive sentence in paragraph 8 is: "If the ground on which reassessment is found to be initiated is untenable, then there is no question of any other ground coming forth in the reassessment proceedings being utilized for the purpose of determining escapement of income."

What was the only ground in the section 148 notices?
This is the detail that limits how far the ruling travels. The Court read the notices as confined to the TDS default and the consequential disallowance under section 40(a)(i). It was not deciding a case where the reasons to believe listed several free-standing issues.
The High Court had earlier left DTAA questions to the reassessment and had negatived a limitation challenge. Those side issues did not keep the reassessment alive once the foundational TDS ground failed before the Supreme Court.
For the wider reassessment framework and notice stages, see the income tax notices and appeals stage guide and section 143(2) notice missing in reassessment.
Worked example: a ₹2.4 crore remittance and a collapsing disallowance
The figures are illustrative. An Indian company remits ₹2,40,00,000 in the year to its overseas parent for technical services. No tax is withheld under section 195. The Assessing Officer reopens under section 147 on the single ground that the remittance attracts TDS and the expense must be disallowed under section 40(a)(i).
Assume an effective tax rate of 25.168% (22% plus surcharge and cess) and that the parallel section 201 order is later deleted by the ITAT on a finding that the payee had no Indian tax liability.
Expense sought to be disallowed under section 40(a)(i): ₹2,40,00,000
Tax on that addition at 25.168%: ₹60,40,320
If section 201 interest and tax were also demanded on the same remittance, that demand falls with the ITAT win
After LG Electronics logic: the foundational ground is untenable, so the reassessment cannot be kept alive on a newly discovered issue
What changes on the file: once the ITAT section 201 order is final (or is not appealed for low tax effect, as in LG), produce it with the Supreme Court holding. The ₹60.4 lakh demand tied to that disallowance has no surviving foundation if the notice never named another reason.
What does not automatically change: a notice that separately recorded, say, an unexplained credit or a transfer-pricing issue as an independent reason to believe. Those facts need their own analysis.

Practice guide for professionals
Amended Form 3CD: A Practical Guide (₹299) works clause by clause through the tax audit disclosures that most often become additions, including disallowances linked to TDS defaults. The ₹699 bundle has all four practice guides.
Can the Assessing Officer still use other grounds mid-reassessment?
The Court was express. Because the notice under section 147/148 was only with respect to the section 201 default and section 40(a)(i) disallowance, other grounds coming forth in the reassessment could not be used to determine escapement once that ground became untenable.
Read that as authority for notices confined to a failed foundational ground. Do not stretch it into a rule that every addition the Assessing Officer spots mid-reassessment always dies, regardless of what the notice said.
Situation | What LG Electronics supports | What to check first |
|---|---|---|
Notice confined to TDS / 40(a)(i); parallel s.201 finally fails | Reassessment unenforceable; produce SC + ITAT orders | Exact reasons recorded with the s.148 notice |
Notice lists several independent reasons | LG does not automatically wipe the others | Which reasons still stand on their own facts |
AO discovers a new issue during reassessment | Cannot save a notice whose only ground failed | Whether the new issue was in the recorded reasons |
Only the quantum appeal is pending | Plead the confined-notice + failed-foundation chain | Stay of demand if recovery has begun |
If recovery has started while you sort the notice challenge, see stay of demand in income tax.
How does this sit with Jet Airways, Ranbaxy and Explanation 3?
Before LG Electronics, practitioners argued this space through the High Court split on Explanation 3 to section 147 (inserted by the Finance Act, 2009) and cases such as CIT v. Jet Airways (I) Ltd. (Bombay High Court) and Ranbaxy Laboratories Ltd. v. CIT (Delhi High Court). Those decisions dealt with whether, once a valid reassessment is on, other escaped income can also be assessed.
Two cautions keep the article accurate:
LG Electronics is Supreme Court authority on a notice confined to a ground that later became untenable through a parallel final finding. That is a narrower, and for those facts stronger, proposition than a general ban on assessing other income.
Post-Finance Act 2021 the section 147 wording changed, and some Tribunal decisions (for example Paceman Sales Promotion Pvt. Ltd., Kolkata ITAT, as discussed in practitioner writing) treat "other income" under the newer text differently. Map your assessment year before citing either line.
Explanation 3 and the Jet Airways / Ranbaxy debate remain relevant where the original recorded reason survives and the dispute is only about additions beyond it.
For the 2025 Act reassessment structure, see income tax reassessment under the 2025 Act and section 148 reassessment framework.
What changes under the Income-tax Act, 2025?
From 1 April 2026 the Income-tax Act, 2025 replaces the 1961 Act. Section 536(2) keeps the 1961 Act for proceedings on tax years beginning before 1 April 2026, so LG Electronics continues to matter for older assessment years, including the AYs before the Court.
Point | 1961 Act | 2025 Act |
|---|---|---|
Income escaping assessment | Section 147 | Section 279 |
Notice where income has escaped | Section 148 | Section 280 |
Disallowance: interest / royalty / FTS to non-resident without TDS | Section 40(a)(i) | Section 35(b)(ii) |
TDS on payments to non-residents | Section 195 | Section 393 |
Consequence of failure to deduct / assessee-in-default | Section 201 | Section 398 |
Powers of survey | Section 133A | Section 253 |
Section 280 still requires a notice before assessment or reassessment under section 279. The LG Electronics logic — a notice confined to a failed foundational ground cannot be rescued by later issues — is the pleading to test against the new sections when those years come up.
For the wider appeals transition, see income tax appeals under the 2025 Act vs 1961.
Decision checklist
Pull the recorded reasons / section 148 notice. Is the escapement confined to TDS / PE / section 40(a)(i), or are there independent reasons?
Is there a parallel section 201 (or section 398) order, and what is its present status before the ITAT or High Court?
Has any assessment against the non-resident payee been quashed or become final for low tax effect?
Does the ITAT (or higher forum) finding remove the withholding obligation under section 195 / 393?
Have you a certified set of the Supreme Court order and the ITAT section 201 order ready to produce?
If a demand is outstanding, is a stay application or appeal clock running?
For AYs governed by the 2025 Act, have you mapped 147/148/40(a)(i)/195/201/133A to 279/280/35(b)(ii)/393/398/253?
Common mistakes
Citing LG Electronics for every mid-reassessment addition without reading whether the notice was confined
Ignoring a live parallel section 201 appeal that still supports the Revenue's TDS theory
Treating a Non-Reportable label as if the order has no operative force
Mixing Jet Airways / Explanation 3 arguments with LG's failed-foundation holding without separating the facts
Letting the Assessing Officer keep the file open after you have the ITAT and Supreme Court papers in hand
Missing the stay / appeal deadline while waiting for a writ-style closure
Practitioner insights
Put the notice text and the ITAT section 201 operative portion on one page. The Supreme Court case turned on that match.
Ask whether any other reason in the notice can stand without the TDS theory. If none can, LG Electronics is your lead authority.
Where the notice is broader, plead LG for the TDS limb and keep Jet Airways / Explanation 3 / post-2021 wording for the rest.
Watch low-tax-effect closures on the non-resident's assessment. In LG, those orders were not challenged and still fed the section 201 win.
Close the loop in writing: covering letter, SC order, ITAT order, and a request to drop the reassessment as unenforceable.
Frequently asked questions
Does a failed original ground always kill the entire reassessment?
In Principal Officer, LG Electronics India Pvt. Ltd. v. ACIT, Noida (C.A. Nos. 18067, 18068 and 18281 of 2017, Supreme Court, 7 October 2026), the Court held the reassessment unenforceable because the section 148 notices were confined to a single TDS / section 40(a)(i) ground that had become untenable after a final ITAT finding under section 201. If your notice listed independent reasons, read the notice text carefully before relying on LG.
What was the parallel section 201 finding in LG Electronics?
The ITAT held that there was no tax liability on LG Korea, so the Indian company had no obligation to withhold tax under section 195 and was not an 'assessee-in-default' under section 201. The Supreme Court said a section 40(a)(i) disallowance cannot then survive, and no remand was needed.
Can the Assessing Officer add other issues discovered during reassessment?
Where the notice itself was confined to one failed ground, the Supreme Court said other grounds cannot be used to determine escapement. Older High Court case law on Explanation 3 to section 147 (Jet Airways, Bombay; Ranbaxy, Delhi) and post-Finance Act 2021 wording still need a separate reading when the notice is broader.
Is the LG Electronics order a reportable judgment?
The signed order is labelled Non-Reportable. It remains a Supreme Court decision that closes the reassessment for those assessment years on production of the Supreme Court and ITAT orders before the Assessing Officer.
Which sections of the 2025 Act replace sections 147 and 148?
Income escaping assessment is section 279 and the notice is section 280. Section 40(a)(i) maps to section 35(b)(ii), section 195 to section 393, section 201 to section 398, and section 133A survey to section 253. Section 536(2) keeps the 1961 Act for tax years beginning before 1 April 2026.
What should I produce to the Assessing Officer after a win like this?
The Supreme Court directed the assessee to produce the Court decision and the ITAT section 201 order (Annexure A1) before the Assessing Officer, who shall close the reassessment as unenforceable. Keep certified copies and a short covering note tying the notice ground to the ITAT finding.
Does this help if only a CIT(A) or ITAT appeal on the reassessment is pending?
LG was decided in appeals against High Court refusal to interfere with the section 148 notices. If you are already in appeal on the reassessment order, the same chain — notice confined to TDS / 40(a)(i), parallel section 201 win — is the pleading to put first.
Related reading
Sources
Principal Officer, LG Electronics India Pvt. Ltd. thr. its Authorized Signatory Mr. Ashish Agrawal v. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Noida & Anr., Civil Appeal Nos. 18067 of 2017, 18068 of 2017 and 18281 of 2017 (Supreme Court, 7 October 2026, J.B. Pardiwala and K. Vinod Chandran JJ.), Non-Reportable order, official PDF on the Supreme Court of India website (api.sci.gov.in). Income-tax Act, 1961: sections 40(a)(i), 133A, 147, 148, 195 and 201. Income-tax Act, 2025 (as amended by Finance Act 2026): sections 35(b)(ii), 253, 279, 280, 393, 398 and 536. Older High Court discussion of Explanation 3 to section 147: CIT v. Jet Airways (I) Ltd. (Bombay) and Ranbaxy Laboratories Ltd. v. CIT (Delhi), as commonly cited in reassessment literature. Figures in the worked example are illustrative. Educational content only; not advice on any particular case.
Guides and toolkits
Practice guides at ₹299 each, or ₹699 for all four.
This is an educational publication for professionals. It is not an offer of professional services.




Comments