Got a Final Tax Order Without a Draft First? Bombay HC Says It Can't Stand
A scrutiny assessment ends with a final order, a demand notice and a penalty notice, all on the same day. Months earlier, a Transfer Pricing Officer had made an adjustment. But nobody ever sent a draft order.
That missing step is not a technicality. On 30 October 2026, the Bombay High Court quashed exactly such an order, and refused to let the department go back and fix it.
Quick answer: If you are an eligible assessee (a TP adjustment, or a non-resident or foreign company), the Assessing Officer must first serve a draft order under section 144C (section 275 of the Income-tax Act, 2025). A final order passed without it is a jurisdictional defect, and the Bombay High Court has set such orders aside without remand.
Contents
Why is a missing draft order such a big deal?
Section 144C gives an eligible assessee a choice the ordinary taxpayer does not have. On receiving a draft order, it can object before the Dispute Resolution Panel (DRP), a collegium of three Principal Commissioners or Commissioners.
If it objects, the DRP's directions bind the Assessing Officer, and the final order goes straight to the ITAT. If it does not, it can still appeal to the CIT(A). Skipping the draft takes away that choice altogether.
The draft order comes 'in the first instance', irrespective of anything to the contrary in the Act (section 144C(1); section 275(1)).
No demand notice or penalty notice should follow a draft order, because a draft is not an assessment.
The final order is passed only after acceptance, silence for 30 days, or DRP directions.
For a full comparison of the two routes, see our guide to DRP versus CIT(A) in transfer pricing cases.
What did the Bombay High Court decide on 30 October 2026?
In Orpak Systems India Pvt. Ltd. v. The Assessment Unit (NFAC) & Ors., Writ Petition No. 424 of 2026, a Division Bench of Justices B. P. Colabawalla and Farhan P. Dubash decided the case on 30 October 2026.
Assessment year 2022-23. The company filed a return declaring a business loss of ₹27,19,53,542.
The TPO's order under section 92CA(3) dated 10 January 2025 made an upward adjustment of ₹2,41,67,387.
The faceless unit then passed a final order under section 143(3) read with section 144B on 24 March 2025, cutting the loss to ₹24,77,86,155. Demand and penalty notices (sections 156 and 274 read with 270A) were issued the same day.
The Revenue's own written instructions admitted that no draft order had been passed and called it an 'inadvertent procedural lapse', asking for a remand.
The court held that sections 144B(1)(xxi) to (xxix) apply section 144C to faceless assessments, so a draft had to be served before any final order. It quashed the final assessment order, following its earlier rulings in Danfoss Fluid Power (29 September 2025), Barentz India (13 October 2025) and SHL (India) Pvt. Ltd. v. DCIT, (2021) 438 ITR 317 (Bom).
On remand, the bench said there was no reason to send the matter back. Whether the officer can now start again with a fresh draft was expressly left open.
Who is an eligible assessee entitled to a draft order?
Section 144C(15)(b) of the 1961 Act, and section 275(17)(b) of the 2025 Act, define an eligible assessee as:
Any person in whose case the variation arises as a consequence of a TPO order under section 92CA(3) (section 166(6) of the 2025 Act). This includes resident Indian companies, as in Orpak.
Any non-resident (not being a company), or any foreign company, for any prejudicial variation, even with no transfer pricing at all.
The draft route does not apply to an order passed with the Principal Commissioner's approval in a GAAR case (section 144C(14A); section 275(16)). Under the 2025 Act it also excludes block assessments of search cases under sections 292 and 295 (section 275(18) and (19)).

Non-resident individuals often miss this. For how notices to NRIs work in general, see our guide to income tax notices for NRIs.
Worked example: a ₹2.42 crore TP adjustment with no draft
Take the Orpak figures. Returned loss: ₹27,19,53,542. TP adjustment: ₹2,41,67,387. Assessed loss in the final order: ₹24,77,86,155.
The loss available to carry forward falls by ₹2.42 crore.
Illustration only: if the company later sets off that loss against profits taxed at 25.168% (section 115BAA rate with surcharge and cess), the future tax cost of the adjustment is about ₹60.8 lakh.
Because the order was passed without a draft, the company never got to argue the ₹2.42 crore before the DRP, whose directions would have bound the officer.
Result: the High Court quashed the order. The question whether a new draft can now be issued is left open.
A loss case has no immediate demand, so it is tempting to ignore the order. That is a mistake: a reduced loss is a real tax cost later, and the appeal clock starts on the final order.
Practice guide for professionals
Amended Form 3CD: A Practical Guide (₹299) covers clause-by-clause reporting in the tax audit report that the assessment unit reads when it frames scrutiny issues. The ₹699 bundle has all four practice guides.
What are the timelines once a draft order is served?
Step | Time limit | Provision (1961 / 2025 Act) |
|---|---|---|
Accept or object to the draft | 30 days from receipt of the draft | 144C(2) / 275(2) |
Final order if accepted or no objection | One month from end of the month in which acceptance is received or the 30 days expire | 144C(4) / 275(4) |
DRP directions | Nine months from end of the month in which the draft is forwarded | 144C(12) / 275(13) |
Final order after DRP directions | One month from end of the month in which directions are received; no further hearing | 144C(13) / 275(14) |
Appeal against order after DRP | Direct to ITAT | 253(1)(d) / 362(1)(d) |
Appeal if no objections filed | CIT(A), then ITAT | 246A / 357 |

The DRP can confirm, reduce or enhance the variations, and can consider any matter arising out of the assessment, even one you did not raise. It cannot set aside a variation for fresh enquiry (section 144C(8); section 275(8) and (9)).
Worked example: a non-resident with no TP issue
Ravi, a non-resident individual working in Dubai, is in scrutiny. The faceless unit proposes an addition of ₹40 lakh. There is no TPO reference.
Ravi is still an eligible assessee, because he is a non-resident other than a company.
Tax effect, assuming the 30% slab and 4% cess and no surcharge: about ₹12.48 lakh, before interest.
Suppose the draft is received on 10 December 2026. Objections to the DRP and the AO are due by 9 January 2027.
If Ravi files nothing, the final order is due by 28 February 2027 (one month from end of January 2027).
If he objects, the DRP must issue directions by 30 September 2027 (nine months from end of December 2026).
If instead a final order with a demand arrives with no draft at all, Ravi's first ground is jurisdiction, not the merits of the ₹40 lakh.
Writ or appeal: which remedy fits?
The Bombay High Court entertained writ petitions in Orpak, Danfoss and SHL despite the appeal remedy, because the defect goes to the officer's power to pass the order.
A writ suits a clear, admitted failure: the order sheet shows no draft, and you are an eligible assessee on the face of the record.
An appeal within time keeps the merits alive if the writ court declines to interfere. Raise the missing draft as an additional legal ground.
If a demand is enforced meanwhile, apply for a stay; see
.
The same logic, that some steps are conditions of jurisdiction rather than formalities, runs through the Supreme Court's 2026 ruling on the missing section 143(2) notice.
Old and new section map
Subject | Income-tax Act, 1961 | Income-tax Act, 2025 |
|---|---|---|
Reference to DRP and draft order | Section 144C | Section 275 |
Eligible assessee | Section 144C(15)(b) | Section 275(17)(b) |
GAAR orders excluded | Section 144C(14A) | Section 275(16) |
Reference to TPO / TPO order | Section 92CA(1) / 92CA(3) | Section 166(1) / 166(6) |
Faceless assessment | Section 144B | Section 273 |
Scrutiny assessment order | Section 143(3) | Section 270(10) |
Time limit for assessment | Section 153 | Section 286 |
Mistakes not to invalidate | Section 292B | Section 522 |
Notice of demand | Section 156 | Section 289 |
Penalty for under-reporting | Section 270A | Section 439 |
Appeal to CIT(A) | Section 246A | Section 357 |
Appeal to ITAT | Section 253 | Section 362 |
For which Act governs a pending proceeding, see our note on appeals under the 2025 Act.
Decision checklist
Are you an eligible assessee: TPO order, non-resident individual, or foreign company?
Was the variation prejudicial: an addition, or a reduction in loss?
Check the e-proceedings tab and order sheet: was a draft order under section 144C(1) ever issued?
Was a demand notice or penalty notice issued with the order? That signals a final order, not a draft.
Note the date of service of the final order and diarise the appeal deadline.
Is the time limit under section 153 / section 286 already over? That affects whether a fresh draft is possible.
Decide: writ on jurisdiction, appeal with the legal ground, or both.
Common mistakes
Treating a final order as a draft. Filing DRP objections against a final order does not help; check the heading and whether a demand notice was raised.
Ignoring a loss case. A cut in carried-forward loss is a future tax cost, as the Orpak numbers show.
Forgetting non-resident status. An NRI with no TP issue is still an eligible assessee.
Letting the appeal time lapse. A pending writ does not stop the appeal clock unless the court says so.
Missing the 30 days on a valid draft. Once the window closes without objections, the AO can complete the assessment on the draft, and the DRP route is lost.
Arguing only merits. Where no draft was issued, lead with jurisdiction; the merits can follow.
Practitioner insights
Ask for, or download, the full order sheet. In Orpak, the Revenue's own instructions admitted that no draft existed.
Keep a TP file ready from the Form 3CEB stage. Weak documentation hurts more when the DRP route is open; see
.
In faceless cases, a show-cause notice under section 144B is not the same as a draft order under section 144C. Our
explains the show-cause stage.
Bombay High Court rulings bind authorities within its jurisdiction and are persuasive elsewhere. Check your own High Court's view before choosing a writ.
Track the outer time limit. A quashed order late in the limitation period may leave the department no time for a fresh draft, but that question remains open.
Frequently asked questions
What is a draft assessment order under section 144C?
It is a draft of the proposed assessment that the Assessing Officer must first send to an eligible assessee when he proposes a variation prejudicial to it. The assessee then has 30 days to accept it or object before the Dispute Resolution Panel. Under the Income-tax Act, 2025 the same rule is in section 275.
Who is an eligible assessee for the Dispute Resolution Panel?
Any person whose variation arises from a Transfer Pricing Officer's order, and any non-resident (not being a company) or foreign company. See section 144C(15)(b) of the 1961 Act and section 275(17)(b) of the 2025 Act.
What happens if the AO passes a final order without a draft order?
The Bombay High Court has held, in SHL (India) (2021) and again in Orpak Systems India (30 October 2026), that this is a jurisdictional defect, not a procedural lapse. The final order was quashed and the court refused the Revenue's request to remand the matter.
Can section 292B save an assessment passed without a draft order?
No, according to the Bombay High Court in SHL (India), quoted and followed in Orpak. Section 292B (section 522 of the 2025 Act) cures mistakes and omissions in a valid proceeding; it cannot give the Assessing Officer a jurisdiction he did not have.
Can the department issue a fresh draft order after the final order is quashed?
The High Court in Orpak left this question open. It said the officer may do so only if he is otherwise entitled in law. The time limit under section 153 (section 286 of the 2025 Act) will usually decide whether a fresh draft is still possible.
Should I file a writ or an appeal when no draft order was issued?
Bombay High Court has entertained writ petitions because the defect goes to jurisdiction. Many taxpayers also file an appeal within time to protect their position. The choice depends on facts, the stage reached and the court's view; the appeal time limit keeps running meanwhile.
Does this rule apply to resident taxpayers without transfer pricing?
No. A resident whose assessment has no variation flowing from a TPO order is not an eligible assessee, so no draft order is required in the normal scrutiny route. In a faceless assessment, such a taxpayer should still get a show-cause notice under section 144B before any prejudicial variation.
Related reading
Sources
Orpak Systems India Pvt. Ltd. v. The Assessment Unit (NFAC) & Ors., Writ Petition No. 424 of 2026, Bombay High Court, order dated 30 October 2026 (B. P. Colabawalla and Farhan P. Dubash, JJ.), referring to Danfoss Fluid Power Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India (WP 10403 of 2025, 29 September 2025), Barentz India Pvt. Ltd. v. Assessment Unit, NFAC (WP 1460 of 2025, 13 October 2025) and SHL (India) Pvt. Ltd. v. DCIT, (2021) 438 ITR 317 (Bom). Income-tax Act, 1961, sections 92CA, 143(3), 144B, 144C, 153, 156, 246A, 253, 270A, 274 and 292B. Income-tax Act, 2025, sections 166, 270, 273, 275, 286, 289, 357, 362, 439 and 522 (text from incometaxindia.gov.in). The tax computations in the examples are illustrative. Educational content only; not advice on any particular case.
Guides and toolkits
Practice guides at ₹299 each, or ₹699 for all four.
This is an educational publication for professionals. It is not an offer of professional services.




Comments