top of page
CA India Logo.png

PGT & ASSOCIATES

Chartered Accountant Firm

Reassessed Without a Section 143(2) Notice? The Supreme Court Says It Fails

Nov 5
10 min read

The reassessment order is on your desk. You filed the return the AO asked for, replied to every questionnaire, attended every hearing. But look closely at the file: was a notice under section 143(2) ever actually issued after that return?

On 28 October 2026 the Supreme Court made that question decisive again. If the answer is no, the reassessment cannot stand, however fully you took part in it.

Quick answer: In PCIT v. Orissa Mining Corporation Ltd., 2026 INSC 1171, the Supreme Court held that a section 143(2) notice is a sine qua non for reassessment under section 147. Its absence is not cured by your participation, by section 292BB, or by a section 142(1) letter. Under the 2025 Act, the same notice sits in section 270(8).

Section 143(2) notice not issued in reassessment: Supreme Court in PCIT v. Orissa Mining Corporation 2026 holds section 292BB cannot cure it

Contents

What did the Supreme Court decide on 28 October 2026?

A bench of Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva dismissed the Revenue's appeals in a batch led by PCIT, Bhubaneswar v. Orissa Mining Corporation Ltd. The assessment years ran from 2008-09 to 2011-12.

The assessments had been reopened under section 147. In response to the section 148 notices, one assessee asked that its original return be treated as the return in response, and another refiled the same return. Admittedly no section 143(2) notice followed. The AO issued section 142(1) letters and framed reassessment orders.

The Court answered three questions, all against the Revenue:

  1. Participation is not a cure. Section 292BB does not stop an assessee from objecting to the non-issue of a section 143(2) notice merely because it appeared and cooperated without objecting.

  2. Relying on the earlier return changes nothing. The Revenue must still serve the notice even where the assessee asks that its section 139 return be treated as the return in response to section 148.

  3. A section 142(1) letter is no substitute. A letter asking the assessee to explain the grounds of reassessment does not amount to compliance with section 143(2).

In the Court's words, a notice under section 143(2) "is sine qua non for a proceeding for reassessment under Section 147 of the Act. In the absence of a notice under Section 143(2) of the Act, no further proceedings can be undertaken by the Revenue."

Why is the section 143(2) notice so important?

Section 143(2) is the step that converts a return into a scrutiny case. It tells the assessee that the AO doubts the return and gives a date to produce evidence in support of it. Only after that can the AO make an assessment under section 143(3).

The Supreme Court has treated it as jurisdictional for more than fifteen years:

  • ACIT v. Hotel Blue Moon (2010) 321 ITR 362 (SC): even in a block assessment, omission to issue the notice "cannot be a procedural irregularity" and is not curable.

  • CIT v. Laxman Das Khandelwal (2019) 417 ITR 325 (SC): section 292BB cures infirmities in service of a notice that emanated from the department, not the complete absence of notice.

  • PCIT v. Orissa Mining Corporation Ltd., 2026 INSC 1171: the same rule applies with full force to reassessment, and neither participation nor a section 142(1) letter fills the gap.

The notice matters only when the AO wants to examine a return. Where no return is filed in response to the section 148 notice, the AO proceeds to a best judgment assessment, and the section 143(2) argument generally does not arise.

For how scrutiny cases are selected and handled in the first place, see income tax scrutiny assessment explained.

Worked example: a ₹42 lakh reassessment

The figures are illustrative. Kiran's case for AY 2019-20 is reopened over cash deposits. Kiran files a return in response to the section 148 notice declaring the same income as originally returned.

The AO issues two section 142(1) questionnaires, Kiran replies to both, and the reassessment order adds ₹42,00,000 under section 69A, taxed under section 115BBE.

  • Tax at 60% under section 115BBE: ₹25,20,000

  • Surcharge at 25% of that tax: ₹6,30,000

  • Health and education cess at 4%: ₹1,26,000

  • Tax demand before interest and penalty: ₹32,76,000, that is 78% of the addition

Scenario A: no section 143(2) notice was ever issued. This is the Orissa Mining situation. The reassessment is without jurisdiction, and the whole ₹32.76 lakh demand, with interest and any linked penalty, falls with it. Kiran's replies to the questionnaires do not change this.

Scenario B: the notice was issued but served late, and Kiran objected in writing before the order. The proviso to section 292BB keeps the objection alive, and the timing of service becomes a live legal ground.

Scenario C: the notice was issued, served late, and Kiran participated without ever objecting. Section 292BB deems the notice duly served in time. The legal ground is lost and the case has to be fought on merits.

Worked example of a ₹42 lakh section 69A addition taxed at 78% under section 115BBE and how a missing section 143(2) notice changes the outcome

Practice guide for professionals

Amended Form 3CD: A Practical Guide (₹299) works clause by clause through the tax audit disclosures that most often turn into additions in scrutiny and reassessment. The ₹699 bundle has all four practice guides.

Does section 292BB save the department?

Section 292BB, in force from 1 April 2008, says that where an assessee has appeared in a proceeding or cooperated in an inquiry relating to an assessment or reassessment, any notice required to be served is deemed to have been duly served in time. The assessee cannot then object that the notice was:

  • not served,

  • not served in time, or

  • served in an improper manner.

Two limits follow from the text and the case law:

  • It deals with service, not existence. The fiction assumes a notice was issued. Where the Revenue itself accepts that no notice was sent, the provision "will have no applicability" (Orissa Mining).

  • It does not apply if you objected in time. The proviso excludes cases where the assessee raised the objection before the assessment or reassessment was completed.

Flowchart of section 143(2) notice outcomes: never issued, only section 142(1) letter, served late with objection, served late without objection, with section 292BB and section 523

What is the time limit for the notice?

For a return under section 139, the proviso to section 143(2) bars service of the notice after three months from the end of the financial year in which the return is furnished. Section 270(9) of the 2025 Act carries the same rule.

Return furnished on

Financial year

Notice must be served by

31 July 2025

2025-26

30 June 2026

15 September 2025

2025-26

30 June 2026

10 April 2026

2026-27

30 June 2027

The statute uses the word "served", not "issued". A notice dated within time but delivered after the deadline is open to challenge, which is exactly the objection section 292BB extinguishes if you participate silently. Record the date and mode of receipt the day the notice arrives.

For returns filed in response to a reassessment notice, the decisive point after Orissa Mining is that the notice must precede the reassessment. For the reopening stage itself, see section 148A and 148 notices.

How do you check whether a notice was issued?

Do not rely on memory or the email inbox alone. Build the notice history from the record:

  1. e-Proceedings on the e-filing portal: list every notice for the assessment year with its section, date and Document Identification Number (DIN).

  2. The assessment order itself: faceless orders usually recite the notices issued. Check whether a section 143(2) notice appears after the date of the return filed in response to section 148.

  3. Email and registered post records: note the date each notice was actually received.

  4. Inspection of records: if the position is unclear, apply in writing to the AO for inspection of the assessment record or a copy of the order sheet.

  5. The remand report or Revenue's reply in appeal: once the ground is raised, ask that the Revenue state on record whether and when the notice was issued.

The cleanest case is the one in Orissa Mining, where the Revenue admitted no notice was issued. Where the record is merely silent, the burden of proving issue and service will be argued, so evidence matters.

When and how should you raise the ground?

  • During the reassessment: if the notice was served late or irregularly, object in writing before the order is passed. That is what the proviso to section 292BB requires.

  • Before the CIT(A): take it as a specific ground in Form 35, or as an additional ground if missed. The Supreme Court in Jute Corporation of India Ltd. v. CIT (1991) 187 ITR 688 recognised the first appellate authority's power to entertain additional grounds.

  • Before the ITAT: a pure legal ground on facts already on record can be raised for the first time (NTPC Ltd. v. CIT (1998) 229 ITR 383 (SC)). File a short application for admission of the additional ground.

  • Argue merits too: never run the jurisdiction ground alone. If the Tribunal finds a notice was in fact issued, you need the merits on record.

For the procedure and drafting at the Tribunal, see ITAT procedure and strategy.

What changes under the Income-tax Act, 2025?

From 1 April 2026 the Income-tax Act, 2025 replaces the 1961 Act, but the architecture of this defence is unchanged.

Point

1961 Act

2025 Act

Notice requiring evidence in support of the return

Section 143(2)

Section 270(8)

Time limit for serving that notice

Proviso to section 143(2)

Section 270(9)

Scrutiny assessment order

Section 143(3)

Section 270(10)

Best judgment assessment

Section 144

Section 271

Notice to file return for reassessment

Section 148

Section 280

Income escaping assessment

Section 147

Section 279

Notice for inquiry and documents

Section 142(1)

Section 268(1)

Notice deemed valid on participation

Section 292BB

Section 523

Mistakes not to invalidate proceedings

Section 292B

Section 522

Two drafting points in the new Act are worth noting. Section 280(2) treats a return filed in response to a reassessment notice as a return under section 263, so section 270(8) is triggered. Section 280(3) says a return filed after the period allowed in the notice is not deemed a return under section 263, which the Revenue may use to argue no section 270(8) notice was needed.

For the full reassessment framework under the new law, see reassessment under the Income-tax Act, 2025.

Decision checklist

  • Did you file a return in response to the section 148 or section 280 notice, or ask that the earlier return be treated as filed in response? Note the date.

  • Is there a section 143(2) or section 270(8) notice dated after that return? Check the section number on the notice, not just its heading.

  • If one exists, when was it actually served, and was that within the time limit?

  • Did you object in writing before the order, if service was late or irregular?

  • Were the only communications section 142(1) or section 268(1) questionnaires?

  • Is the ground in Form 35, or does it need to be added as an additional ground?

  • Are the merits fully argued as a fallback?

Common mistakes

  • Treating a section 142(1) questionnaire as if it were the section 143(2) notice

  • Replying to everything without first checking which notices exist and on what dates

  • Noticing late service but objecting only after the order, which section 292BB then defeats

  • Running only the legal ground in appeal and leaving the merits unargued

  • Assuming that asking the AO to treat the original return as the response waives the notice: Orissa Mining says it does not

  • Missing the appeal deadline while building the jurisdiction argument. If that has happened, see condonation of delay in income tax appeals.

Practitioner insights

  • Write the notice history as a dated table in the appeal paper book. A one-page chronology of return, notices and order often decides this ground.

  • Ask the Revenue to confirm on record whether a section 143(2) notice was issued. An admission, as in Orissa Mining, ends the debate.

  • Keep the ground separate from service objections. Non-issue cannot be cured; late service can be, so plead both precisely.

  • Expect the department to rely on section 292B or section 522 as a general saving clause. The Supreme Court's reasoning treats the notice as jurisdictional, not as a mere defect.

  • Check linked penalties. If the reassessment falls, a penalty based on it should fall too.

Frequently asked questions

Is a section 143(2) notice mandatory in reassessment?

Yes, where the assessee files a return in response to the section 148 notice and the AO wants to examine it. The Supreme Court in PCIT v. Orissa Mining Corporation Ltd., 2026 INSC 1171 (28 October 2026), held that the notice is a sine qua non for reassessment under section 147 and that no further proceedings can be taken without it.

Does section 292BB cure the absence of a section 143(2) notice?

No. Section 292BB (section 523 of the 2025 Act) only deems a notice that was actually issued to have been properly and timely served. It cannot create a notice that was never issued. This was held in CIT v. Laxman Das Khandelwal (2019) 417 ITR 325 (SC) and reaffirmed in Orissa Mining.

If I asked the AO to treat my original return as filed under section 148, is a 143(2) notice still needed?

Yes. In Orissa Mining the Supreme Court held that the Revenue is not absolved of its obligation to serve a section 143(2) notice merely because the assessee asked that the earlier return be treated as the return in response to the section 148 notice.

Can a section 142(1) questionnaire replace the section 143(2) notice?

No. The Supreme Court held that a letter under section 142(1) asking the assessee to explain the grounds of reassessment does not satisfy section 143(2). A later letter 'would not validate what is non est'.

What is the time limit for issuing a section 143(2) notice?

For a return under section 139, the notice must be served within three months from the end of the financial year in which the return is furnished. Under the Income-tax Act, 2025 the same rule is in section 270(9). A return filed on 15 September 2025 therefore needs the notice served by 30 June 2026.

Can I raise the missing-notice ground for the first time before the ITAT?

Generally yes. It is a pure legal ground going to jurisdiction, and the Supreme Court in NTPC Ltd. v. CIT (1998) 229 ITR 383 allowed new legal grounds to be raised before the Tribunal where the facts are on record. File it as an additional ground with a short application.

Does the Orissa Mining ruling apply to the Income-tax Act, 2025?

The judgment interprets the 1961 Act. The 2025 Act keeps the same structure: the notice is in section 270(8), its time limit in section 270(9) and the deemed-service rule in section 523. The reasoning should carry over, though no court has yet ruled under the new Act.

Related reading

Sources

PCIT, Bhubaneswar v. Orissa Mining Corporation Ltd., 2026 INSC 1171 (SC, 28.10.2026, SLP (C) No. 14546 of 2023); ACIT v. Hotel Blue Moon (2010) 321 ITR 362 (SC); CIT v. Laxman Das Khandelwal (2019) 417 ITR 325 (SC); NTPC Ltd. v. CIT (1998) 229 ITR 383 (SC); Jute Corporation of India Ltd. v. CIT (1991) 187 ITR 688 (SC). Income-tax Act, 1961: sections 69A, 115BBE, 139, 142(1), 143(2), 143(3), 144, 147, 148, 292B, 292BB. Income-tax Act, 2025 (as amended by the Finance Act, 2026): sections 263, 268(1), 270(8)-(10), 271, 279, 280, 522, 523. Figures are illustrative. This article is for education and is not advice on any particular case.

Guides and toolkits

Practice guides at ₹299 each, or ₹699 for all four.

This is an educational publication for professionals. It is not an offer of professional services.

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page