The Department Appealed Your Tax Win? Check This ₹60 Lakh Limit First
You won before the CIT(A). Months later, a notice arrives: the department has filed an appeal before the Tribunal. Before you start drafting a defence, there is one number worth checking.
If the tax at stake in that year is below the CBDT's monetary limit, and no exception applies, the department was not supposed to file that appeal at all. Many taxpayers never raise the point, and spend years defending a case that the department's own circular says should not exist.
Quick answer: The department should not appeal where the tax effect does not exceed ₹60 lakh before the ITAT, ₹2 crore before a High Court or ₹5 crore before the Supreme Court (CBDT Circular 9/2024). Tax effect is computed year by year, without interest. Exceptions, such as accommodation-entry or foreign-asset cases, are decided on merits.
Contents
Why your appellate win may not be the end
An order of the CIT(A) or the Tribunal in your favour can be taken further by the department: to the ITAT under section 253 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (section 362 of the Income-tax Act, 2025), and onwards to the High Court and Supreme Court.
To cut low-value litigation, section 268A of the 1961 Act, now section 373 of the 2025 Act, lets the CBDT fix monetary limits below which its officers must not appeal. The current instructions are in Circular 5/2024 dated 15 March 2024, as amended by Circular 9/2024 dated 17 September 2024.
The effect is large. In a written reply in the Rajya Sabha on 4 August 2026, the Finance Ministry said that, because of Circular 9/2024, the department had withdrawn 443 appeals from the ITAT, 4,791 from High Courts and 744 from the Supreme Court, and had not filed 11,390, 5,565 and 534 appeals respectively.
What are the current monetary limits for departmental appeals?
Forum | Limit (tax effect) | Before 17 Sep 2024 |
|---|---|---|
Income Tax Appellate Tribunal | ₹60 lakh | ₹50 lakh |
High Court | ₹2 crore | ₹1 crore |
Supreme Court (SLP or appeal) | ₹5 crore | ₹2 crore |
Two points in the circulars are easy to miss:
The limits cover TDS and TCS cases too (Circular 9/2024, para 3), subject to the TDS exceptions discussed below.
Crossing the limit is not a reason to appeal. Para 4.2 of Circular 5/2024 says an appeal should not be filed merely because the tax effect exceeds the limit; the decision is to be taken on merits.
Pending appeals are covered. Circular 9/2024 applies to appeals already pending before the Tribunal, High Courts and Supreme Court, which may accordingly be withdrawn.
If you want the bigger picture of each appeal stage, the income tax notices and appeals guide sets out the route from notice to Tribunal.
How is 'tax effect' worked out?
Para 5.1 of Circular 5/2024 defines tax effect as the difference between the tax on the total income assessed and the tax that would have been chargeable had that income been reduced by the issues the department wants to appeal on (the 'disputed issues').
Include surcharge and cess.
Exclude interest, unless the chargeability of interest is itself the dispute; then the interest is the tax effect.
Loss cases: where a returned loss is reduced or turned into income, take the notional tax on the disputed additions.
Penalty orders: the tax effect is the amount of penalty deleted or reduced.
MAT or AMT cases: para 5.2 gives a formula that adds the effect under the normal provisions and under section 115JB or 115JC (now section 206 of the 2025 Act).
TDS and TCS: take the cumulative effect of all orders for that year of the deductor, including interest under section 201(1A) (section 398 of the 2025 Act) (para 5.4).
Para 5.3 adds the rule that matters most in multi-year disputes: tax effect is calculated separately for every assessment year and every assessee, even when a single composite order covers them all.
Worked example: ₹2.1 crore of additions deleted for a company
A domestic company taxed under section 115BAA (effective rate 25.168%, being 22% plus 10% surcharge plus 4% cess) was assessed for AY 2022-23 with two additions: ₹1.35 crore of disallowed sub-contract charges and ₹75 lakh under section 14A. The CIT(A) deleted both.
Item | Amount |
|---|---|
Additions deleted by the CIT(A) | ₹2,10,00,000 |
Tax rate including surcharge and cess | 25.168% |
Tax effect (₹2.1 crore × 25.168%) | ₹52,85,280 |
ITAT limit | ₹60,00,000 |
Interest under sections 234B and 234D | Ignored |
The tax effect of ₹52.85 lakh is below ₹60 lakh. Unless the case falls in an exception, the department should not appeal to the Tribunal, and if it does, the company has a strong preliminary objection.
Change one fact: suppose the sub-contract charges were treated as bogus purchases from entry operators. That may bring the case within the 'accommodation entries' exception, in which case the department can appeal on merits whatever the amount.
Practice guide for professionals
Amended Form 3CD: A Practical Guide (₹299) covers clause-by-clause tax audit reporting, where many of the disallowances that later become appeal issues first show up. The ₹699 bundle has all four practice guides.
Worked example: one order, three assessment years
An individual's appeals for three years are decided by one composite CIT(A) order, deleting additions of the same type. The department's tax effect, year by year, is shown below.

Added together, the tax effect is ₹1.41 crore. But para 5.3 tests each year on its own, so the department may appeal only for AY 2020-21. It should not appeal for AY 2019-20 or AY 2021-22, even though the issue is identical.
For the taxpayer, this changes strategy. Two years are effectively final, and only one needs a full defence before the Tribunal.
When do the limits not protect you?
Para 3.1 of Circular 5/2024 lists cases where the decision to appeal is taken on merits, without regard to the tax effect. In summary:
A provision of the Act, Rules or a notification has been held constitutionally invalid, or a Board circular, instruction or order has been held illegal or ultra vires.
The assessment is based on information about an offence under another law from law enforcement or intelligence agencies such as the CBI, ED, DRI, SFIO, NIA, NCB, DGGI, state police or GST departments.
The department has filed a prosecution in the case and the trial is pending, or there is a conviction that has not been compounded.
Strictures or adverse comments have been passed, or costs levied, against the department or its officers.
The tax effect is not quantifiable or not involved, such as registration of trusts, or orders under section 263 (section 377 of the 2025 Act).
Undisclosed foreign income, foreign assets or foreign bank accounts.
Organised tax evasion, including bogus capital gains or losses through penny stocks and accommodation entries.
Appeals mandated by a court's directions, writ matters, and matters under laws other than the Income-tax Act, such as wealth tax or equalisation levy.
TDS/TCS disputes on the nature of a transaction (whether tax had to be deducted at all), and international taxation disputes on the applicability of a tax treaty.
Any other class of cases the Board specifies by circular.
Para 3.2 adds cases deferred under section 158AB (section 376 of the 2025 Act), where an identical question is pending in another case: once that question reaches finality in the department's favour, the deferred appeal can proceed regardless of the limit.

The department appealed anyway: what can you do?
Compute the tax effect yourself, year by year. Use the assessment order, the appellate order and the issues in the department's grounds of appeal. Keep the working on file.
Read the grounds for an exception. If the grounds call your case one of 'accommodation entries' or 'information from an agency', check whether the assessment order was actually based on such material.
Raise a preliminary objection. File a short written submission before the first hearing stating the tax effect, the limit, and that no para 3.1 exception applies. Attach the computation.
Consider a cross-objection on time. Under section 253(4) of the 1961 Act (the corresponding cross-objection provision in section 362 of the 2025 Act), you can file cross-objections within 30 days of receiving notice of the department's appeal. Use it if you have your own grounds, for example on jurisdiction.
Prepare on merits anyway. If the Tribunal holds that an exception applies, the appeal will be heard on merits. Do not let the preliminary point be your only defence.
If a departmental appeal also leaves a demand outstanding for another year, keep the stay of demand options in view, and if you have missed a filing date of your own, see how condonation of delay works.
Does 'no appeal' mean the department accepted the issue?
No. Section 268A(2) and (3) of the 1961 Act, now section 373(2) and (3) of the 2025 Act, say that not appealing because of a monetary limit does not stop the department from appealing on the same issue for another year or another assessee, and the taxpayer cannot argue that the department has 'acquiesced'.
Para 6.1 of Circular 5/2024 requires the PCIT or CIT to record that the decision is not accepted and that the appeal is not being filed only because of the low tax effect. So a favourable order that went unchallenged for monetary reasons is useful, but it is not a settled position you can rely on for later years.
Old and new section map
Subject | Income-tax Act, 1961 | Income-tax Act, 2025 |
|---|---|---|
Monetary limits for departmental appeals | Section 268A | Section 373 |
Appeal to the Tribunal; cross-objections | Section 253 | Section 362 |
Revision by the PCIT/CIT | Section 263 | Section 377 |
Deferral of appeals on identical questions | Section 158AB | Section 376 |
Interest on TDS default | Section 201(1A) | Section 398 |
Book profit (MAT) and AMT | Sections 115JB and 115JC | Section 206 |
Appeals for AY 2026-27 and earlier years continue under the 1961 Act procedure, through the transition provisions in section 536 of the 2025 Act, and existing circulars continue so far as they are consistent with the new Act.
Decision checklist
Which forum is the department appealing to: ITAT, High Court or Supreme Court?
What is the tax effect of the issues in the department's grounds, for each assessment year separately?
Have you excluded interest, unless interest itself is in dispute?
For a penalty, what amount was deleted or reduced?
Does any para 3.1 exception genuinely apply on the facts of the assessment order?
Is a cross-objection needed, and is the 30-day window still open?
Is your defence on merits ready in case the preliminary objection fails?
Common mistakes
Adding years together. The test is per year and per assessee.
Including interest. Interest under sections 234A to 234D is not part of the tax effect unless its levy is the issue.
Computing on all additions, not the appealed ones. Only issues the department has actually appealed on count.
Ignoring the 'not merely because' rule. Above the limit, the department still has to justify the appeal on merits.
Treating a low-tax-effect win as precedent for later years. Section 373(3) of the 2025 Act bars the 'acquiescence' argument.
Raising the objection late. Put it in writing before the hearing, with the computation.
Practitioner insights
The exceptions turn on what the assessment was based on, not on the label in the appeal memo. Ask the departmental representative to point to the material in the record.
In TDS cases, include interest under section 201(1A) in your computation; leaving it out can understate the tax effect and weaken your objection.
Where a composite order covers many years, a year-wise table on one page is often the most persuasive document you can file.
Keep track of related penalty proceedings. A quantum win often leads to the penalty being dropped, and the penalty appeal has its own tax effect; see penalty timelines when an appeal is pending.
Revisit old pending appeals. Because Circular 9/2024 reaches pending matters, a short letter to the CIT(DR) pointing out the low tax effect can prompt a withdrawal.
Frequently asked questions
What is the monetary limit for the income tax department to appeal to the ITAT?
₹60 lakh of tax effect, under CBDT Circular 9/2024 dated 17 September 2024. Unless an exception in Circular 5/2024 applies, the department should not file an appeal where the tax effect does not exceed that figure.
What are the limits for appeals to the High Court and the Supreme Court?
₹2 crore for an appeal to a High Court and ₹5 crore for an SLP or appeal to the Supreme Court. Before 17 September 2024 the three limits were ₹50 lakh, ₹1 crore and ₹2 crore.
Does interest count in the tax effect?
No. Tax effect is tax plus surcharge and cess on the disputed issues, without interest. The only exception is where the chargeability of interest is itself the issue in dispute; then the interest is the tax effect.
Is tax effect calculated for all years together?
No. It is worked out separately for each assessment year and each assessee, even where one composite order covers several years. The department can appeal only for the years that cross the limit.
Do the limits apply to appeals that were already pending?
Yes. Circular 9/2024 says it applies to appeals and SLPs pending before the Tribunal, High Courts and Supreme Court, which may be withdrawn. A Rajya Sabha reply of 4 August 2026 reported 443 ITAT, 4,791 High Court and 744 Supreme Court appeals withdrawn.
Can the department appeal a penalty deletion below ₹60 lakh?
For a penalty order, the tax effect is the penalty deleted or reduced. If that amount is ₹60 lakh or less and no exception applies, the department should not appeal to the ITAT.
Are these limits still valid after the Income-tax Act, 2025?
The power to fix limits is now in section 373 of the 2025 Act (formerly section 268A). Circulars issued under the 1961 Act continue so far as they are consistent with the new Act, and the government confirmed the Circular 9/2024 limits in Parliament in August 2026.
Related reading
Sources
Income-tax Act, 1961: sections 158AB, 201, 253, 263 and 268A.
Income-tax Act, 2025: sections 206, 362, 373, 376, 377, 398 and 536.
CBDT Circular No. 5/2024 dated 15 March 2024 (F.No. 279/Misc.142/2007-ITJ(Pt.)), paras 3, 4, 5 and 6.
CBDT Circular No. 9/2024 dated 17 September 2024 (F.No. 279/Misc./M-74/2024-ITJ).
PIB press release on enhanced monetary limits for appeals, September 2024.
Rajya Sabha Unstarred Question No. 1829, answered on 4 August 2026, on monetary limits for tax appeals.
Educational content only. It is not legal or tax advice; facts differ, so check the current law and the full circulars before acting.
Guides and toolkits
Practice guides at ₹299 each, or ₹699 for all four.
This is an educational publication for professionals. It is not an offer of professional services.




Comments