top of page
CA India Logo.png

PGT & ASSOCIATES

Chartered Accountant Firm

Penalty Passed While Your ITAT Appeal Was Pending? Delhi High Court Quashed It

Nov 6
11 min read

You filed the appeal at the ITAT, told the Assessing Officer, and assumed the penalty file would wait. Then a section 270A penalty order and demand notice arrive anyway, with the Tribunal yet to hear a word.

On 13 October 2026 the Delhi High Court quashed exactly such an order. Here is what it held, where the statute is less straightforward than the headline, and how to act on a file like yours.

Quick answer: In BT Global Communications India Pvt. Ltd. v. NFAC (W.P.(C) 4767/2023), a Division Bench of the Delhi High Court quashed a section 270A penalty order passed while an ITAT appeal was pending. It read section 275(1)(a) as requiring penalty proceedings to stay in abeyance, and held that informing the AO was immaterial. The AO may begin again if the Tribunal rules against the assessee. Under the 2025 Act the limitation rule sits in section 472.

Penalty order passed during ITAT appeal: Delhi High Court in BT Global Communications 2026 reads section 275(1)(a) as keeping section 270A penalty in abeyance

Contents

What did the Delhi High Court decide on 13 October 2026?

A Division Bench of Justice Dinesh Mehta and Justice (Dr.) Aditi Choudhary allowed a writ petition by BT Global Communications India Pvt. Ltd. against a penalty order for assessment year 2018-19. The order carries no neutral citation and is cited by case number and date.

The dates matter, so here they are in sequence:

  • 28 July 2022: assessment order under section 143(3) read with section 144C(13). The AO recorded satisfaction for penalty and issued a section 270A notice the same day.

  • 17 August 2022: the company replied to the penalty notice.

  • 29 August 2022: the company appealed to the ITAT under section 253 and informed the AO.

  • 24 March 2023: the AO passed the penalty order while the appeal was pending.

Timeline of BT Global Communications v NFAC: section 270A penalty order passed during pending ITAT appeal and quashed by Delhi High Court under section 275(1)(a)

The Revenue pointed to a line in the penalty order saying the assessee was 'in the process of filing' an appeal. The Court observed that the line appeared to have been taken from the company's first reply of 17 August 2022, and noted that the appeal had in fact been filed and intimated.

It then went further: "Whether intimation was given or not, is immaterial". Section 275(1)(a), it said, provides that penalty proceedings shall be kept in abeyance when an appeal under section 253 is pending.

The Court quashed the penalty order. The AO is free to take up penalty proceedings afresh if the Tribunal decides the appeal against the company and the law permits.

What does section 275(1)(a) actually say?

Section 275 is titled 'Bar of limitation for imposing penalties'. Its sub-section (1) says no penalty order shall be passed after certain dates, depending on what stage the underlying order has reached.

Clause

When it applies

Outer limit for the penalty order

275(1)(a)

Relevant order is under appeal to the JCIT(A) or CIT(A) (ss.246/246A) or the ITAT (s.253)

Later of the end of the financial year in which the proceedings were completed, or six months from the end of the month in which the appellate order is received by the PCIT or CIT

Proviso to 275(1)(a)

CIT(A) order passed on or after 1 June 2003

Before the end of that financial year, or within one year from the end of the financial year in which the CIT(A) order is received, whichever is later

275(1)(b)

Order is under revision (ss.263/264)

Six months from the end of the month in which the revision order is passed

275(1)(c)

Any other case

Later of the financial year-end of completion, or six months from the end of the month in which penalty action is initiated

275(1A)

Penalty order passed before the appellate order is received

May be passed or revised on the revised assessment, after hearing the assessee, within six months from the end of the month of receipt

Read on its own, clause (a) fixes an outer time limit. Sub-section (1A) separately provides for penalty orders made before an appeal is decided.

The Delhi High Court treated clause (a) as an abeyance rule. As reproduced, the order quotes clause (a) and its proviso but does not discuss sub-section (1A). Whether other High Courts and Tribunals will read the clause the same way remains to be seen.

For how appeals reach the Tribunal and what happens there, see ITAT procedure and strategy.

Worked example: a ₹48 lakh addition and a ₹6.04 lakh penalty

The figures are illustrative. A company is assessed under section 143(3) read with section 144C(13) on 30 June 2025 for AY 2023-24, with a ₹48,00,000 disallowance and a penalty notice under section 270A issued the same day.

The company appeals to the ITAT on 22 August 2025. On 12 January 2026 the AO passes a penalty order for under-reporting. The ITAT has not yet heard the appeal. Assume an effective tax rate of 25.168% (22% plus 10% surcharge plus 4% cess).

  • Tax on the under-reported income: ₹48,00,000 × 25.168% = ₹12,08,064

  • Penalty at 50% for under-reporting: ₹6,04,032

  • Penalty at 200% if misreporting were established: ₹24,16,128

  • Financial year of completion: 2025-26, ending 31 March 2026

On a pure limitation reading, the order of 12 January 2026 is within time, because the later date under clause (a) is at least 31 March 2026 and the ITAT order has not been received.

On the Delhi High Court's reading, the order is premature because a section 253 appeal is pending. It would be quashed, with liberty to restart if the ITAT upholds the addition.

What the ITAT outcome does: if the ITAT deletes the ₹48 lakh, there is no under-reported income and no penalty base. If it reduces the addition, the penalty is recomputed on the revised figure under section 275(1A). Paying the ₹6.04 lakh early would only create a refund claim.

Four checks on a section 270A penalty order: pending ITAT appeal under section 275(1)(a), under-reporting versus misreporting notice, limitation, and forum with section 249 time limit

Practice guide for professionals

Amended Form 3CD: A Practical Guide (₹299) works clause by clause through the tax audit disclosures that most often become additions, and then penalty proceedings. The ₹699 bundle has all four practice guides.

Does the ruling cover a CIT(A) appeal too?

The ruling dealt with a pending ITAT appeal under section 253. Clause (a) of section 275(1) also names appeals to the JCIT(A) or CIT(A), but the Court was not asked about, and did not decide, a CIT(A) appeal.

For a CIT(A) appeal the provision has its own proviso, which runs to one year from the end of the financial year in which the CIT(A) order is received. Treat that case as open and compute the limitation dates carefully:

Situation

Governing clause

What to check first

ITAT appeal pending when penalty order passed

275(1)(a); BT Global (Delhi HC, 2026)

Form 36 filing date against penalty order date

Only a CIT(A) appeal pending

275(1)(a) and proviso; not decided in BT Global

Limitation under the proviso; stay of demand

No appeal filed

275(1)(c)

Later of financial year-end or six months from the end of the month of initiation

Penalty order passed early, appellate order follows

275(1A)

Hearing given; order within six months from the end of the month of receipt

Take a penalty initiated in an assessment order dated 30 June 2025 with no appeal. Six months from 30 June 2025 is 31 December 2025, but the financial year of completion ends on 31 March 2026. Clause (c) takes the later date, so the limit is 31 March 2026.

What if the penalty order has already been passed?

Move in this order:

  1. Record the dates. Note the date of service of the penalty order and of the demand notice, and the date your Form 36 was filed.

  2. Appeal within 30 days. Section 249(2)(a) gives 30 days from service of the demand notice where the appeal relates to a penalty. Under the 2025 Act the same period is in section 358(3)(a).

  3. Add the section 275 ground. State the ITAT appeal, its filing date and the clause relied on. Add the notice ground from the next section if it fits.

  4. Ask for a stay. A penalty demand is recoverable unless stayed. See stay of demand in income tax.

  5. Consider a writ only for a clear jurisdictional defect. BT Global succeeded by writ, but the appellate route remains the default.

  6. If time has run out, apply for condonation. See condonation of delay in income tax appeals.

Is the penalty notice itself valid?

A second, independent ground deserves a check on every penalty file: did the notice say which charge is alleged?

Section 270A(7) sets the penalty at 50% of the tax on under-reported income. Section 270A(8) raises it to 200% where the under-reporting results from misreporting, a defined list in section 270A(9).

In PCIT (Central)-2 v. Jaina Marketing and Associates (Delhi HC, ITA 500/2024, 23 September 2024), the ITAT had annulled a 200% penalty for AY 2017-18. The notices spoke only of under-reporting, and the ITAT held the assessee could not be expected to answer a misreporting charge never put to it. The High Court did not interfere.

That 2024 order has been re-published by some legal portals this month, so it may appear new. For the wider 270A defence, see section 270A penalty defence at ITAT Ahmedabad.

What changes under the Income-tax Act, 2025?

From 1 April 2026 the Income-tax Act, 2025 replaces the 1961 Act. Section 536(2) of the new Act keeps the 1961 Act, including section 275, for proceedings on tax years beginning before 1 April 2026, so the BT Global analysis applies to older assessment years.

Point

1961 Act

2025 Act

Penalty for under-reporting and misreporting

Section 270A

Section 439

Penalty at 50% / 200% / misreporting list

270A(7) / (8) / (9)

439(9) / (10) / (11)

Hearing and approval before penalty

Section 274

Section 471(1) and (2)

Bar of limitation for penalty orders

Section 275

Section 472

Limitation where the order is under appeal

275(1)(a)

472(1)(c)

Limitation in any other case

275(1)(c)

472(1)(d)

Revision of penalty on revised assessment

275(1A)

472(2) and (3)

Appeal to JCIT(A) / CIT(A)

Sections 246A / 246

Sections 356 / 357

Time limit to appeal against a penalty

Section 249(2)(a)

Section 358(3)(a)

Appeal to the Tribunal

Section 253

Section 362

Two differences are worth noting. Section 472 counts six months from the end of the quarter, not the month, and has no financial-year limb. Where the order is under appeal, section 472(1)(c) runs from receipt of the appellate order.

Also, section 471(4) provides that for assessments or reassessments made on or after 1 April 2027, the penalty under section 439 forms part of the assessment order itself. That will end the separate penalty-order timing question for later years.

Section 472 contains no abeyance wording either. Whether BT Global's reasoning carries over to the new Act is untested. For the wider appeal framework, see income tax appeals under the 2025 Act vs 1961.

Decision checklist

  • Was the assessment order appealed to the ITAT (or CIT(A)), and on what date was Form 36 or Form 35 filed?

  • On what date was the penalty order passed and served? Is the appeal still pending on that date?

  • Which clause of section 275(1) fits the file? Have you computed the dates for it?

  • Does the notice name under-reporting or misreporting, and does the order impose the same charge?

  • Has the AO been informed in writing of the appeal, with the acknowledgement attached?

  • Is the 30-day appeal period running, and is a stay application ready?

  • Are the merits of the addition pleaded in the main appeal, so the penalty base can fall?

Common mistakes

  • Replying to a penalty notice without filing a copy of the appeal acknowledgement on the penalty file

  • Treating a penalty order passed during the appeal as a reason to ignore the 30-day appeal period

  • Assuming BT Global binds every forum. It is a Delhi High Court writ order without a neutral citation

  • Confusing clause (a), clause (c) and sub-section (1A) when computing limitation

  • Ignoring the under-reporting versus misreporting wording of the notice

  • Paying the penalty early and then having to chase a refund after the ITAT outcome

Practitioner insights

  • Put a one-page chronology on the penalty file: assessment date, notice date, appeal date, penalty order date, service date. The Delhi order turned on exactly these dates.

  • Attach proof of the appeal filing to every penalty reply from the day the appeal is filed.

  • Argue the limitation reading and the abeyance reading together. Courts that follow BT Global will apply it, and others may still test the clause (a) time limit.

  • Watch for the Revenue relying on section 275(1A). If it does, the answer lies in how that sub-section interacts with clause (a).

  • Keep the main appeal strong. If the addition falls, the penalty falls with it, which is the real protection.

Frequently asked questions

Can the Assessing Officer pass a section 270A penalty order while my ITAT appeal is pending?

In BT Global Communications India Pvt. Ltd. v. Assessment Unit, NFAC (W.P.(C) 4767/2023, 13 October 2026), a Division Bench of the Delhi High Court quashed a penalty order passed while the ITAT appeal was pending. It read section 275(1)(a) as requiring penalty proceedings to be kept in abeyance. The ruling is a High Court order, so check how your own jurisdiction treats it.

Does it matter if I told the Assessing Officer about my appeal?

The Delhi High Court held that whether intimation was given is immaterial, because section 275(1)(a) operates when an appeal under section 253 is pending. Even so, keep a dated copy of the Form 36 acknowledgement on the penalty file, because it removes any argument about facts.

What is the time limit for passing a penalty order under section 275?

It depends on the clause. Where an appeal is pending, clause (a) gives the later of the end of the financial year in which the proceedings were completed or six months from the end of the month in which the appellate order is received by the PCIT or CIT. In any other case, clause (c) gives the later of the financial year-end or six months from the end of the month in which penalty action was initiated.

Can the department levy the penalty again after the ITAT decides?

Yes, if the Tribunal decides against the assessee and the law permits. The Delhi High Court quashed the order with liberty to the Assessing Officer to take up the penalty proceedings afresh in that event. Section 275(1A) also allows a penalty order to be passed or revised on the basis of the assessment as revised by the appellate order.

Where do I challenge a penalty order passed during the appeal?

The usual route is an appeal to the CIT(A) within 30 days of service of the demand notice under section 249(2) of the 1961 Act, with a stay application for the demand. In BT Global the assessee went to the High Court by a writ petition, which the Court allowed. A writ is generally reserved for a clear jurisdictional defect, so choose the forum with the facts in hand.

Is a section 270A penalty valid if the notice says only under-reporting but the order imposes 200% for misreporting?

The ITAT held in the Jaina Marketing matter (AY 2017-18) that it is not, because the assessee was never told the misreporting charge. The Delhi High Court (ITA 500/2024, 23 September 2024) did not interfere with that order. Under-reporting attracts 50% and misreporting 200%, so the notice must say which charge is made.

Which section replaces section 275 under the Income-tax Act, 2025?

Section 472, titled 'Bar of limitation for imposing penalties', applies to the new Act. Penalty itself is in section 439 and the procedure in section 471. For tax years beginning before 1 April 2026, section 536(2) keeps the 1961 Act, including section 275, in force.

Related reading

Sources

BT Global Communications India Pvt. Ltd. v. Assessment Unit, National Faceless Assessment Centre, W.P.(C) 4767/2023 (Delhi HC, 13.10.2026, Dinesh Mehta and Aditi Choudhary JJ.), judgment text on the research page of lawsathi and report in LiveLaw Business dated 15.10.2026; PCIT (Central)-2 v. Jaina Marketing and Associates, ITA 500/2024 (Delhi HC, 23.09.2024), order on the Delhi High Court portal; Income-tax Act, 1961, sections 249, 253, 270A, 274 and 275 (bare Act text); Income-tax Act, 2025 (as amended by Finance Act 2026), sections 358, 439, 471, 472 and 536, from the Income Tax Department's text. Figures in the worked example are illustrative.

Guides and toolkits

Practice guides at ₹299 each, or ₹699 for all four.

This is an educational publication for professionals. It is not an offer of professional services.

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page