top of page
CA India Logo.png

PGT & ASSOCIATES

Chartered Accountant Firm

Refund Adjusted Against an Old Tax Demand? The Reply That Can Stop It

Nov 11
9 min read

Your return showed a refund. The portal says it has been processed. Then the money never arrives, because it has been quietly set off against a demand from a year you thought was closed.

Often that demand is wrong: already paid, deleted in appeal, reduced by rectification, or stayed. The good news is that the law gives you a window to object before the set-off, and that window matters more than any later appeal.

Quick answer: Before adjusting a refund against an outstanding demand, the department must send a written intimation under section 245 (section 438 of the Income-tax Act, 2025) and consider your response. Reply on the portal within the time given, with reasons and proof. An adjustment made without this step has been quashed by the Delhi High Court.

Contents

Why did my refund shrink, or vanish, without warning?

Section 245(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 lets the Assessing Officer and senior officers, in lieu of paying a refund, set off the refund or any part of it against any sum remaining payable by the same person.

The 2025 Act repeats this in section 438(1). From 1 April 2026, Act 4 of 2026 inserted words that allow the set-off against sums payable under the 1961 Act as well, so arrears of old years remain fully in play.

In practice, most adjustments are proposed by the Centralised Processing Centre (CPC) when it processes a return under section 143(1) (section 270(1) of the 2025 Act), or when an appeal-effect order creates a refund. The trigger is simply that the system shows a demand as outstanding for some year.

  • The demand may be genuine and unpaid.

  • It may have been paid, but the challan was never mapped to that year.

  • It may have been deleted or reduced by a CIT(A), ITAT or rectification order that was never given effect on the system.

  • It may be under appeal and stayed by the AO.

Only the first is a sound reason for set-off. The other three are where most disputes, and most avoidable losses, come from.

What must the department do before it adjusts a refund?

Section 245(1) of the 1961 Act, and section 438(2) of the 2025 Act, require that any set-off be taken only after giving an intimation in writing of the action proposed.

The Delhi High Court, in Court on its Own Motion v. CIT, (2013) 352 ITR 273 (Del), described this as a two-stage action: first a prior intimation, then, after the assessee's reply is considered, an adjustment where justified. The Bombay High Court later directed the department to follow those directions in other cities too (Arun Ganesh Jogdeo v. Union of India).

In a 2014 writ (WP(C) 6172/2014), the Delhi High Court quashed an adjustment because the intimation and the adjustment were made on the same day. It relied on Glaxo SmithKline Asia (P) Ltd. v. CIT, (2007) 290 ITR 35 (Del), which describes the power as discretionary, signalled by the word 'may'.

Infographic in navy and gold: how a refund can lawfully be set off against an income tax demand under section 245 (section 438 of the 2025 Act) - refund due, written intimation, assessee's response, decision - and the 60-day withholding limit

How do you reply to a section 245 intimation on the portal?

The intimation reaches your registered email and appears on the e-filing portal under Pending Actions, in the Response to Outstanding Demand facility. The response options are broadly three:

  1. Demand is correct: you accept it. The refund will be adjusted, or you can pay.

  2. Demand is partially correct: you accept part and dispute the rest, giving the correct figure.

  3. Disagree with demand: you dispute it fully and choose a reason, such as demand already paid, demand reduced or deleted by an appellate or rectification order, appeal pending, or stay granted.

For each disputed item, upload the evidence: the challan (BSR code, date, serial number), the appellate or rectification order, the appeal acknowledgement, or the stay order. A bare 'disagree' with no document rarely survives.

Infographic in navy and gold: which response fits your outstanding income tax demand - demand is correct, partly correct, or disagree - with documents to upload and interest rates of 1% on demands and 0.5% on refunds

Worked example: a ₹3.4 lakh refund against a disputed ₹5.1 lakh demand

Assume a salaried professional's return for AY 2025-26, filed by the due date, is processed with a refund of ₹3,40,000. The portal also shows a demand of ₹5,10,000 for AY 2018-19 from a scrutiny order.

  • She appealed to the CIT(A) and paid 20% of the disputed demand, ₹1,02,000.

  • The AO granted a stay of the balance ₹4,08,000 till the appeal is disposed of.

  • CPC sends an intimation under section 245 proposing to adjust the full ₹3,40,000 against the AY 2018-19 demand.

Her reply: 'Disagree with demand', reason 'appeal pending and stay granted', uploading the appeal acknowledgement, the ₹1,02,000 challan and the AO's stay order.

Outcome

Refund in hand

Demand position

Reply accepted

₹3,40,000 plus interest

₹4,08,000 remains stayed until the appeal is decided

No reply; adjusted

Nil

Demand falls to ₹68,000 (₹4,08,000 less ₹3,40,000)

Adjusted, later wins appeal

₹3,40,000 back after appeal effect

Interest at 0.5% a month runs on the refund

If the appeal is decided, say, 14 months later and the demand is deleted, interest on ₹3,40,000 at 0.5% a month for 14 months is ₹23,800. The money comes back, but the business lost the use of it for over a year. A short, documented reply avoids that.

Practice guide for professionals

Amended Form 3CD: A Practical Guide (₹299) walks through clause-by-clause tax audit reporting, the source of many processing adjustments that later turn into outstanding demands. The ₹699 bundle has all four practice guides.

Can a refund be adjusted against a demand under appeal or stayed?

A demand under appeal is still a 'sum remaining payable' unless the taxpayer is treated as not in default. Section 220(6) of the 1961 Act (section 411(12) of the 2025 Act) lets the AO grant that relief for the amount in dispute while the appeal is pending.

CBDT's Office Memorandum of 29 February 2016, as modified on 31 July 2017, generally allows a stay on payment of 20% of the disputed demand, subject to exceptions. Where that stay has been granted, adjusting the stayed balance through a refund defeats it, and the stay order should be cited in your reply.

For how to obtain the stay in the first place, see our guide to stay of demand. If the demand itself flows from a computational mistake, rectification may be faster than an appeal.

Can the AO simply hold the refund while an assessment is pending?

Section 245(2), inserted by the Finance Act, 2023 in place of the old section 241A, and now section 438(3) of the 2025 Act, allows withholding only on three conditions:

  • Assessment or reassessment proceedings must actually be pending.

  • The AO must record reasons in writing and obtain the prior approval of the Principal Commissioner or Commissioner.

  • The refund can be withheld only up to 60 days from the date on which the assessment or reassessment is made.

If a refund is held longer, or without recorded reasons and approval, ask for a copy of the reasons and the approval. Note that the withholding period is excluded only when computing the additional 3% interest on appeal-effect refunds (section 437(5)); ordinary refund interest is unaffected.

Worked example: refund adjusted against a demand that no longer exists

A trading firm's refund of ₹1,85,000 for AY 2025-26 is adjusted against a demand of ₹2,20,000 for AY 2016-17. That demand had been reduced to nil by a rectification order in 2022, but the order was never updated on the system. The intimation and the adjustment carry the same date.

  1. File a response on the portal stating 'demand reduced by rectification order', uploading the 2022 order.

  2. Write to the jurisdictional AO asking for the demand to be corrected on the system and the adjusted ₹1,85,000 to be re-issued.

  3. Raise a grievance on the e-filing portal if nothing moves.

  4. If the department still does not act, a writ petition is a recognised remedy, given the same-day adjustment quashed in WP(C) 6172/2014.

  5. Claim interest under section 244A (section 437 of the 2025 Act) in the re-issued refund.

Before replying to any old demand, also check whether it was wiped out by CBDT's order under section 119 of 13 February 2024, which remitted small outstanding demands (up to ₹25,000 per year up to AY 2010-11 and ₹10,000 per year for AY 2011-12 to 2015-16, capped at ₹1 lakh per taxpayer).

Old and new section map

Subject

Income-tax Act, 1961

Income-tax Act, 2025

Set-off of refund against demand

245(1)

438(1)

Prior written intimation

245(1)

438(2)

Withholding while assessment pending

245(2)

438(3)

Interest on refunds

244A

437

Stay: not in default during appeal

220(6)

411(12)

Notice of demand

156

289

Processing of return

143(1)

270(1)

Rectification

154

287

Appeal to the CIT(A)

246A

357

Decision checklist

  • Download the outstanding demand list for every year from the portal, not just the one in the intimation.

  • Match each demand with challans, appellate orders, rectification orders and stay orders.

  • Note the response date on the intimation and diarise it.

  • Choose correct, partly correct or disagree, demand by demand.

  • Upload documents for every disputed item.

  • If an appeal is pending without a stay, decide whether to seek one now.

  • Keep the response acknowledgement and follow up with the AO if CPC adjusts anyway.

Common mistakes

  • Ignoring the intimation because 'the demand is obviously wrong'. Silence is read as acceptance.

  • Replying 'disagree' with no reason or document.

  • Forgetting that appellate relief is not automatic on the system until an appeal-effect order is passed.

  • Assuming a 1961 Act demand died when the 2025 Act came in. It did not.

  • Paying a demand that is under stay just to release a refund, without weighing the interest cost.

For the appeal-effect step, see how appeal-effect orders and refund interest work. For adjustments made at the processing stage itself, see our guide to section 143(1)(a) adjustments.

Practitioner insights

  • Compare the interest rates. An unpaid demand carries interest at 1% a month under section 220(2) (section 411 of the 2025 Act), while a refund earns 0.5%. If you are likely to lose the appeal, letting the set-off happen can be the cheaper choice.

  • Clean the ledger before filing. Most painful adjustments are against demands that should have been closed years ago. A yearly review of the outstanding demand page prevents them.

  • Read the intimation date against the adjustment date. If they match, or no intimation was ever served, the procedural defect is strong ground for reversal.

  • Keep stay orders handy. A stay order on record is the single most persuasive document against a set-off.

Frequently asked questions

What is an intimation under section 245?

It is a written notice that the department proposes to set off a refund due to you against a demand outstanding for another year. Under the Income-tax Act, 2025 the same power and the same intimation requirement are in section 438(1) and (2).

How many days do I get to respond to a section 245 intimation?

The Act itself does not fix a period. CPC intimations usually ask for a response within 30 days through the e-filing portal. If no response is received, the demand is generally treated as accepted and the refund is adjusted.

Can my refund be adjusted without any prior intimation?

No. Section 245 requires an intimation in writing before the set-off. The Delhi High Court in Court on its Own Motion v. CIT (2013) 352 ITR 273 called it a two-stage action, and in WP(C) 6172/2014 it quashed an adjustment made on the same day as the intimation.

Can a refund be adjusted against a demand that is under appeal?

The law does not bar it outright, because a disputed demand is still payable unless stayed. But the power is discretionary, and where the AO has stayed the demand on payment of the standard 20% (CBDT Office Memorandum of 31 July 2017), adjusting the stayed balance defeats the stay. Point to the stay order in your reply.

Do I get interest if my refund was wrongly adjusted?

Interest on refunds under section 244A (section 437 of the 2025 Act) is 0.5% for every month or part of a month. If a wrongful adjustment is reversed, ask for the refund with interest; delay attributable to the department does not reduce it.

Can the department withhold a refund because scrutiny is pending?

Yes, but only within limits. Under section 245(2) of the 1961 Act, now section 438(3) of the 2025 Act, the AO must record reasons and take the PCIT or CIT's approval, and can withhold the refund only up to 60 days from the date the assessment or reassessment is made.

Can a refund under the 2025 Act be set off against an old 1961 Act demand?

Yes. From 1 April 2026, section 438(1) was amended by Act 4 of 2026 to allow set-off against any sum remaining payable under the Income-tax Act, 1961 or the 2025 Act. Old arrears therefore still need cleaning up.

Related reading

Sources

  • Income-tax Act, 1961: sections 143(1), 154, 156, 220, 244A, 245 (as amended by the Finance Act, 2023).

  • Income-tax Act, 2025: sections 270, 287, 289, 411, 437 and 438 (section 438(1) as amended by Act 4 of 2026, w.e.f. 1 April 2026), text from incometaxindia.gov.in.

  • Court on its Own Motion v. CIT, (2013) 352 ITR 273 (Del), judgment dated 14 March 2013 in W.P.(C) 2659/2012.

  • Delhi High Court, W.P.(C) 6172/2014, 2014:DHC:5422-DB (October 2014), following Glaxo SmithKline Asia (P) Ltd. v. CIT, (2007) 290 ITR 35 (Del).

  • Arun Ganesh Jogdeo v. Union of India (Bombay High Court), directing compliance with the Delhi High Court's directions.

  • CBDT Office Memoranda dated 29 February 2016 and 31 July 2017 on stay of demand; CBDT order under section 119 dated 13 February 2024 on remission of outstanding demands.

Educational content only. It is not legal or tax advice; facts differ, so check the current law and your own records before acting.

Guides and toolkits

Practice guides at ₹299 each, or ₹699 for all four.

This is an educational publication for professionals. It is not an offer of professional services.

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page