Won Your Tax Appeal but the Refund Never Came? The AO Has a Deadline
The Tribunal deleted the addition months ago. Yet the e-filing portal still shows the old demand, the 20% you paid for a stay is still with the department, and a new refund for another year has quietly been adjusted against a demand that no longer exists.
Winning the appeal is only half the job. The other half is the order giving effect to it, and the law puts the Assessing Officer on a clock for that.
Quick answer: The AO must give effect to a CIT(A) or ITAT order within six months from the end of the month in which it reaches the Principal Commissioner (section 286(1) of the 2025 Act; three months under old section 153(5)). Miss that, and you earn 3% a year extra on the refund under section 437(4), earlier section 244A(1A).

Contents
Why does the demand still show after you win?
An appellate order does not change the demand on the portal by itself. The CIT(A) or ITAT decides the issues. The AO then has to pass a separate order that recomputes income, tax and interest in line with that decision.
Until that order is passed and uploaded, the system keeps treating the original demand as outstanding. That is why you may see:
The full demand still showing under "Response to outstanding demand"
Reminders or recovery notices on a demand the Tribunal has deleted
Refunds of other years adjusted against the deleted demand
Interest on the demand still being calculated at 1% a month
The law also treats a demand under appeal as valid until the last appellate authority disposes of the appeal (section 411(2) of the 2025 Act). So an order giving effect is what actually closes the loop.
How long does the AO have to give appeal effect?
It depends on what the appellate order asks the AO to do. The clock runs from the end of the month in which the order is received by the jurisdictional Principal Commissioner or Commissioner, not from the date you download it.
What the order requires | 1961 Act | 2025 Act: s.286(1) Table |
|---|---|---|
Simple recomputation (addition deleted, relief allowed) | s.153(5): 3 months, plus up to 6 more with Pr. CIT approval | Sl. No. 10: 6 months, extendable to 9 months |
Effect needs verification of documents or a hearing | s.153(5) second proviso: the s.153(3) period | Sl. No. 9: one year |
Assessment set aside for a fresh assessment | s.153(3) | Sl. No. 5: one year from end of the financial year |
Fresh assessment to give effect to a finding or direction | s.153(6) | Sl. No. 8: one year from end of the month |
Note the shift. Under the 1961 Act the base period was three months. The 2025 Act starts at six. That moves the date from which additional interest begins, so check which version applies to the order you are dealing with.
Worked example: a ₹4 lakh refund after an ITAT win
The figures and dates are illustrative.
Facts. An assessment for an earlier year raised a demand. Meera paid ₹2,40,000 on 1 October 2024 to get a stay and another ₹1,60,000 on 1 April 2025. The ITAT deleted the addition in full, and the order reached the Principal Commissioner on 12 May 2026.
Appeal-effect deadline: six months from the end of May 2026, so 30 November 2026 (assuming no extension)
Refund due: the full ₹4,00,000 paid towards the deleted demand
Interest at 0.5% a month from each payment date, assuming the refund is granted on 31 March 2027: ₹2,40,000 × 0.5% × 30 = ₹36,000 and ₹1,60,000 × 0.5% × 24 = ₹19,200
Additional interest for December 2026 to March 2027: ₹4,00,000 × 3% × 4/12 = ₹4,000
Total refund with interest: ₹4,59,200
What changes the outcome. If Meera delayed the proceedings, for example by not responding to a verification request, that period is excluded from the interest (section 437(7)). If the deadline was formally extended to nine months, additional interest starts only after the extended date.

Practice guide for professionals
Amended Form 3CD: A Practical Guide (₹299) works clause by clause through the tax audit disclosures that most often turn into additions, and then into appeals. The ₹699 bundle has all four practice guides.
How is interest on the refund calculated?
Two layers of interest apply to a refund that comes out of an appellate order.
Regular interest: 0.5% for every month or part of a month. For tax paid against a demand, it runs from the date of payment to the date the refund is granted (section 437(1), Table Sl. No. 3; earlier section 244A(1)(b)).
Additional interest: 3% a year on the refund, from the day after the appeal-effect deadline to the date of grant (section 437(4); earlier section 244A(1A)). It applies only where effect is given without a fresh assessment.
Interest on the demand: if you paid interest at 1% a month on the demand, it is reduced in proportion and the excess is refunded (section 411(6); earlier section 220(2) proviso).
The 10% threshold that blocks interest on small refunds applies only to advance tax, TDS and self-assessment refunds, not to tax paid against a demand. The Supreme Court in Union of India v. Tata Chemicals Ltd. (2014) 363 ITR 658 described such interest as a statutory, non-discretionary obligation.
Can the refund be adjusted against another demand?

Yes, but not silently. Section 438(1) of the 2025 Act, earlier section 245, lets the department set off a refund against any sum still payable under either Act. Section 438(2) says this can be done only after a written intimation of the proposed action.
In Court on its Own Motion v. CIT (2013) 352 ITR 273, the Delhi High Court read this as a two-stage process: intimation first, then a reply, and only then an adjustment if it is justified. Adjustment by the system without that step was held to be contrary to the law.
Two practical points follow:
Reply to every set-off intimation within the time given. If the demand it targets is stayed, deleted or under rectification, say so and attach the order.
If an adjustment has already been made against a demand that the appeal has since deleted, the appeal-effect order should reverse it and refund the amount with interest.
Separately, section 438(3) allows a refund to be withheld only where an assessment or reassessment is pending, with recorded reasons and the Principal Commissioner's prior approval, and only up to 60 days after that assessment is made.
What if the AO sits on it?
Escalate in steps and keep a paper trail. Each step should be in writing and carry the appellate order.
Written request to the jurisdictional AO, with the appellate order, the date it reached the Principal Commissioner (if known), and your own computation of the refund and interest.
Response on the outstanding demand: on the e-filing portal, disagree with the demand and state that it has been deleted or reduced in appeal, attaching the order.
Grievance on the e-filing portal (formerly e-Nivaran), citing the appellate order and the expired time limit under section 286(1).
Letter to the Principal Commissioner who received the order, since the time limit runs from receipt by that office.
Rectification under section 287 of the 2025 Act (earlier section 154) if the appeal-effect order is passed but miscomputes tax, interest or credits.
Writ petition under Article 226 as a last resort, where the delay is long, unexplained and the statutory route has been exhausted.
If recovery steps are being taken on the deleted demand in the meantime, see how stay of demand works. For CPC-side refund issues unrelated to appeals, see why income tax refunds get delayed.
What if the department appeals further?
The department may appeal from a CIT(A) order to the ITAT within two months (section 362 of the 2025 Act, earlier section 253), and from an ITAT order to the High Court within 120 days (section 365, earlier section 260A).
A further appeal does not suspend the duty to refund under section 435 (earlier section 240) unless an appellate authority grants a stay.
Under CBDT Circular No. 9/2024 dated 17 September 2024, the department generally does not appeal where the tax effect is ₹60 lakh or less (ITAT), ₹2 crore or less (High Court) or ₹5 crore or less (Supreme Court), subject to listed exceptions.
If the department later wins, the demand revives and interest under section 411(3) runs from the end of the period in the first demand notice (section 411(6)(b)). Treat a refund on a contested issue as money that may have to go back.
For how Tribunal appeals are argued and decided, see ITAT procedure and strategy.
Decision checklist
Has the appellate order been uploaded, and when did it reach the Principal Commissioner?
Does it delete, reduce, set aside or remand? Set-aside and remand orders follow different time limits and refund rules.
Does the effect need verification or a hearing? If yes, the one-year limit applies.
Have you listed every payment against the demand, with dates, including stay deposits and past adjustments?
Is any set-off intimation pending a reply?
Have you computed regular and additional interest yourself, so you can check the AO's figures?
Has the department appealed, and is the tax effect above the CBDT limits?
Common mistakes
Waiting quietly for the AO, then losing track of the date the time limit expired
Not informing the AO of the appellate order when the department's copy has not reached the jurisdictional office
Ignoring a set-off intimation, which lets the adjustment go through unchallenged
Accepting an appeal-effect order without checking interest, credits and earlier adjustments
Treating a remand order as a win and expecting an immediate refund
Spending the refund on an issue the department is likely to take to the High Court
Practitioner insights
Your own computation is the strongest tool. A one-page working of tax, interest and refund attached to every request shortens the process.
Additional interest is small in money terms but useful in correspondence. It shows the AO that the time limit is statutory, not a courtesy.
Delays caused by the taxpayer reduce interest. Reply to verification requests promptly and on the portal, not only by email.
Where both a demand for one year and a refund for another are open, reconcile them before replying to a set-off intimation.
For a demand that should have been corrected without an appeal, see rectification or appeal for an income tax demand.
Old and new section numbers
Point | 1961 Act | 2025 Act |
|---|---|---|
Order of CIT(A) | Section 250 | Section 359 |
Order of ITAT | Section 254 | Section 363 |
Time limit for appeal effect | Section 153(5) | Section 286(1), Table Sl. Nos. 9 and 10 |
Fresh assessment after set-aside | Section 153(3), 153(6) | Section 286(1), Table Sl. Nos. 5 and 8 |
Refund on appeal | Section 240 | Section 435 |
Interest on refund; additional interest | Section 244A(1), 244A(1A) | Section 437(1), 437(4) |
Set-off and withholding of refund | Section 245 | Section 438 |
Interest on demand; reduction on appeal | Section 220(2) | Section 411(3), 411(6) |
Rectification | Section 154 | Section 287 |
Notice of demand | Section 156 | Section 289 |
Frequently asked questions
What is an appeal effect order in income tax?
It is the order the Assessing Officer passes to give effect to an appellate order, such as one from the CIT(A) or ITAT. It recomputes the income, tax and interest in line with the appellate decision, reduces or deletes the demand and works out any refund.
What is the time limit for giving effect to a CIT(A) or ITAT order?
Under section 286(1) of the Income-tax Act, 2025 (Table Sl. No. 10), it is six months from the end of the month in which the order reaches the Principal Commissioner or Commissioner, extendable to nine months. If documents must be verified or you must be heard, it is one year (Sl. No. 9). Under section 153(5) of the 1961 Act the base period was three months, extendable by six.
Do I get extra interest if the appeal effect is delayed?
Yes. Section 437(4) of the 2025 Act, earlier section 244A(1A), gives additional interest at 3% a year on the refund, from the day after the appeal-effect time limit expires to the date the refund is granted. It is on top of the normal 0.5% a month and applies only where effect is given without a fresh assessment.
Can the department adjust my appeal refund against another year's demand?
Only after telling you in writing first. Section 438(1) and (2) of the 2025 Act, earlier section 245, require a written intimation of the proposed set-off. The Delhi High Court in Court on its Own Motion v. CIT (2013) 352 ITR 273 described this as a two-stage process: intimation, a chance to reply, then the adjustment.
How do I complain if the AO has not given appeal effect?
Start with a written request to the jurisdictional AO with the appellate order attached, then raise a grievance on the e-filing portal, then write to the Principal Commissioner. If the delay is long and unexplained, a writ petition under Article 226 is the last resort.
Does the department's appeal to the ITAT or High Court stop my refund?
Not by itself. The duty to refund under section 435 of the 2025 Act, earlier section 240, arises from the appellate order. A further appeal by the department does not suspend it unless a stay is granted, but if the department later wins, the demand revives with interest.
When is a refund not due immediately after I win the appeal?
When the assessment is set aside for a fresh assessment, the refund becomes due only once the fresh assessment is made (section 435(2)(a), earlier section 240). If the assessment is annulled, only tax paid above the tax on your returned income is refundable.
Related reading
Sources
Income-tax Act, 1961: sections 153(3), (5), (6), 154, 156, 220(2), 240, 244A, 245, 250, 253, 254, 260A; Income-tax Act, 2025: sections 286(1) (Table Sl. Nos. 5, 8, 9, 10), 287, 289, 359, 362, 363, 365, 411, 435, 437, 438; CBDT Circular No. 9/2024 dated 17.09.2024; Union of India v. Tata Chemicals Ltd. (2014) 363 ITR 658 (SC); Court on its Own Motion v. CIT (2013) 352 ITR 273 (Del). Figures are illustrative. Educational content only, reflecting the law as of 4 November 2026; check the current law and the transition provisions in section 536 of the 2025 Act for your facts.
Guides and toolkits
Practice guides at ₹299 each, or ₹699 for all four.
This is an educational publication for professionals. It is not an offer of professional services.




Comments