top of page
CA India Logo.png

PGT & ASSOCIATES

Chartered Accountant Firm

Missed Your CIT(A) Hearing and the Appeal Was Dismissed? It Isn't Over

Nov 3
9 min read

The appeal was filed on time and the tax on returned income was paid. Then the hearing notices went to an old email address, nobody replied, and the order that finally arrived says the appeal is "dismissed for non-prosecution". The addition stands, and so does the demand.

That order is usually not the end of the road. A Commissioner (Appeals) has a statutory duty to decide an appeal on merits, and the Tribunal regularly sends such cases back. The catch is that the way back has a short deadline.

Quick answer: Under section 250(6) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, now section 359(4) of the Income-tax Act, 2025, a CIT(A) order must state the points for determination, the decision and the reasons. The Bombay High Court has held that a CIT(A) cannot dismiss an appeal for non-prosecution. File an appeal to the ITAT within two months of the order and ask for the matter to be restored.

CIT(A) ex parte order dismissing income tax appeal for non-prosecution and ITAT remedy

Contents

Why do CIT(A) appeals get dismissed ex parte?

Most first appeals are now handled through the faceless appeal system, with notices sent through the e-filing portal and by email. Ex parte orders usually follow one of these patterns:

  • Hearing notices went to an email address or mobile number that is no longer monitored

  • The authorised representative changed and nobody was watching the portal

  • An adjournment request was sent by email instead of being uploaded as a response

  • Written submissions were filed after the last date given in the final notice

  • The assessee assumed nothing would happen until a physical hearing was fixed

For how the faceless system issues notices and how responses are recorded, see how faceless assessment and faceless appeals work.

Can a CIT(A) dismiss an appeal for non-prosecution?

Not validly. In CIT v. Premkumar Arjundas Luthra (HUF) (2016) 240 Taxman 133 (Bom), the Bombay High Court reasoned that once an appeal is filed, the CIT(A) must dispose of it on merits. Section 250(6) requires a written order stating the points for determination, the decision on them and the reasons, and the CIT(A)'s powers are co-terminous with the Assessing Officer's.

The same logic carries over to the 2025 Act, which keeps this wording in section 359(4). The CIT(A) can adjourn the hearing, make further inquiry or call for a remand report under section 359(3), but nothing in sections 359 or 360 provides for dismissal for non-prosecution.

Tribunal benches have followed Luthra in many cases, for example HV Metal ARC (P.) Ltd. v. ACIT (2018) 173 ITD 606 (Delhi), Pawan Kumar Singhal v. ACIT (2019) 178 ITD 390 (Delhi) and DSI-Bridgecon India (P.) Ltd. v. ACIT (2024) 205 ITD 136 (Delhi). In each, the matter went back to the CIT(A) for a speaking order on merits.

Dismissed in limine or decided ex parte on merits?

Read the operative part of the order carefully. The remedy is the same, an appeal to the ITAT, but your grounds change.

Type of order

What it looks like

Your main ground

Dismissed in limine

"Appellant has not complied with notices, appeal dismissed for non-prosecution"

No power to dismiss without deciding the grounds; violation of s.250(6) / s.359(4)

Decided ex parte on merits

Each ground discussed, addition confirmed "in the absence of any submission"

Denial of a reasonable opportunity; evidence on record not considered

Partly decided

Some grounds discussed, others ignored

Grounds left undecided; request remand on those grounds

Worked example: a ₹24 lakh addition and a missed hearing

The figures are illustrative.

Facts. Kiran deposited ₹24,00,000 in cash in AY 2022-23. A best-judgment assessment under section 144 added the full amount as unexplained money under section 69A, taxed under section 115BBE. She appealed to the CIT(A) and paid the tax on her returned income.

Three hearing notices went to an email address she had stopped using. The CIT(A) order, served on 15 July 2026, dismissed the appeal for non-prosecution without discussing any ground.

  • Tax on the addition: ₹24,00,000 × 78% = ₹18,72,000, plus interest (60% tax, 25% surcharge and 4% cess)

  • Last date to appeal to the ITAT: two months from the end of July 2026, so 30 September 2026

  • ITAT fee: assessed income ₹30,00,000, so 1% is ₹30,000, capped at ₹10,000

  • Stay: an application to the AO for a stay, and if needed to the Tribunal, which can grant up to 180 days on 20% of the demand being deposited or secured

  • Main relief sought: set aside the CIT(A) order and restore the appeal for a fresh decision on merits after a hearing

What changes the outcome. Kiran has bank records showing the cash came from withdrawals made earlier in the same year. If she files these before the CIT(A) after restoration, she will need a Rule 46A application, because they were never before the AO.

Worked example of an ex parte CIT(A) order on a section 69A addition with ITAT appeal deadline and fee

Practice guide for professionals

Amended Form 3CD: A Practical Guide (₹299) works clause by clause through the tax audit disclosures that most often turn into additions, and then into appeals. The ₹699 bundle has all four practice guides.

Which remedy fits your case?

Remedies against an ex parte CIT(A) order: ITAT appeal, Rule 46A, ITAT Rule 24 recall and condonation of delay

Situation

Route

Provision

CIT(A) dismissed for non-prosecution

Appeal to ITAT, seek restoration

s.253 (1961 Act); s.362, Form 115 (2025 Act)

CIT(A) decided ex parte, ignoring material on record

Appeal to ITAT on merits and natural justice

s.250(6) / s.359(4)

Evidence never filed before the AO

Rule 46A application after restoration

Rule 46A of the 1962 Rules / Rule 192 of the 2026 Rules

Two-month deadline missed

Appeal with a condonation application

s.253(5) / s.362(5)

Demand being recovered

Stay application to AO, then ITAT

s.254(2A) / s.363(6)

If the deadline has passed, read how condonation of delay works before filing. If recovery has started, see how to get a stay of demand.

Rectification of the CIT(A) order under section 154 (section 287 of the 2025 Act) is rarely the right tool here. Not hearing the appeal is a failure of process, not a mistake apparent from the record.

How to draft the ITAT appeal

  1. Download the CIT(A) order and the full notice history from the e-filing portal, and note the date the order was served.

  2. Ground 1: the CIT(A) erred in dismissing the appeal without deciding the grounds on merits, contrary to section 250(6) / 359(4).

  3. Ground 2: the order was passed without a reasonable opportunity of being heard.

  4. Then repeat each merits ground from the first appeal, so the Tribunal can decide them itself if it chooses.

  5. Explain the non-compliance briefly and honestly, with proof: the changed email address, the representative's change, a medical record.

  6. Attach the submissions and evidence you would have filed, and ask that the matter be restored with a direction to grant a fair hearing.

  7. Pay the correct fee and file a stay application separately if the demand is being pursued.

For how the Tribunal stage works, from paper books to hearings, see ITAT procedure and strategy.

If the ITAT also hears you ex parte

Rule 24 of the Income-tax (Appellate Tribunal) Rules, 1963 lets the Tribunal decide an appeal on merits after hearing the respondent if the appellant does not appear. Its proviso then requires the Tribunal to set aside the ex parte order and restore the appeal if the appellant later shows sufficient cause for not appearing.

  • File the recall application as soon as you learn of the order, with evidence of the reason for non-appearance.

  • Do not confuse it with rectification under section 254(2) (section 363(2) of the 2025 Act), which is limited to mistakes apparent from the record and must be filed within six months from the end of the month in which the order was passed.

  • Expect the Tribunal to look hard at repeated absences. One documented lapse is easier to excuse than a pattern.

Decision checklist

  • Has the order actually been served, and on what date?

  • Does it decide any ground on merits, or simply dismiss?

  • Is the two-month ITAT deadline still open, and if not, can you document the delay?

  • Is the demand being recovered, and has a stay been sought?

  • Do you have evidence that was never before the AO, needing Rule 46A?

  • Are the email, mobile and representative details on the portal now correct?

Common mistakes

  • Writing to the CIT(A) to "reopen" the appeal instead of appealing to the ITAT within time

  • Appealing to the ITAT only on merits and not taking the procedural ground

  • Giving a vague reason for non-compliance with no supporting document

  • Treating the date you noticed the order as the date of service when the portal shows earlier communication

  • Letting refunds be adjusted against the demand because no stay was sought

  • Failing to update contact details, so the restored appeal is missed again

Practitioner insights

  • Tribunals restore these appeals readily, but some do so on terms, such as costs or a direction to cooperate. Plan for one fair chance, not two.

  • Where the record is complete and the issue is legal, ask the Tribunal to decide it itself. A remand adds a year or more.

  • A restored appeal is a fresh opportunity: file a structured written submission with a paper book, not a one-page reply.

  • Review the portal's e-proceedings tab every week while any appeal is pending, and keep a log of every notice and response.

For the full sequence from notice to Tribunal, see the income tax notices and appeals guide.

Old and new section numbers

Point

1961 Act

2025 Act

Appealable orders before CIT(A)

Section 246A

Section 357

Form and time limit of first appeal

Section 249, Form 35

Section 358, Form 99

Procedure; reasoned order

Section 250(4), 250(6)

Section 359(3), 359(4)

Powers of CIT(A)

Section 251

Section 360

Appeal to ITAT

Section 253, Form 36

Section 362, Form 115

ITAT orders, rectification, stay

Section 254(1), (2), (2A)

Section 363(1), (2), (6)

Best-judgment assessment

Section 144

Section 271

Frequently asked questions

Can the CIT(A) dismiss my appeal for non-prosecution?

Not validly, on the view of the Bombay High Court in CIT v. Premkumar Arjundas Luthra (HUF) (2016). Section 250(6) of the 1961 Act, now section 359(4) of the 2025 Act, requires a written order stating the points for determination, the decision on each and the reasons, so the appeal must be decided on merits even if you do not appear.

What should I do if my CIT(A) appeal was dismissed ex parte?

Check the order on the e-filing portal, note its date of service and file an appeal to the ITAT within two months from the end of the month in which it was served. Ask the Tribunal to set aside the order and restore the appeal to the CIT(A), and file the reply or evidence you could not file earlier.

What is the time limit to appeal to the ITAT against a CIT(A) order?

Two months from the end of the month in which the order is communicated to you, under section 253(3) of the 1961 Act and section 362(3) of the 2025 Act. A late appeal can be admitted if you show sufficient cause.

What is the ITAT appeal fee?

₹500 if the assessed total income is ₹1 lakh or less, ₹1,500 if it is above ₹1 lakh and up to ₹2 lakh, and 1% of the assessed income, capped at ₹10,000, above ₹2 lakh. Appeals on other matters, such as penalties, cost ₹500, and a stay application costs ₹500.

Does an ITAT appeal stop recovery of the demand?

No. Filing an appeal does not stay the demand by itself. You need to apply for a stay, first to the Assessing Officer and, if that fails, to the Tribunal, which can grant a stay for up to 180 days on a deposit or security of at least 20% of the demand.

Can I recall an ex parte order passed by the ITAT?

Yes. Under Rule 24 of the Income-tax (Appellate Tribunal) Rules, 1963, if the appeal was disposed of in your absence and you show sufficient cause for not appearing, the Tribunal must set aside the ex parte order and restore the appeal.

Can I file new documents when the ITAT sends the matter back?

Usually the restored appeal is heard afresh, and the CIT(A) considers your submissions. Documents that were never before the Assessing Officer still need an application under Rule 46A of the 1962 Rules, now Rule 192 of the Income-tax Rules, 2026.

Related reading

Sources

Income-tax Act, 1961: sections 69A, 115BBE, 144, 154, 246A, 249, 250, 251, 253, 254; Income-tax Act, 2025: sections 271, 287, 357, 358, 359, 360, 362, 363; Income-tax Rules, 1962, Rule 46A; Income-tax Rules, 2026, Rules 167, 192, 193; Income-tax (Appellate Tribunal) Rules, 1963, Rule 24; CIT v. Premkumar Arjundas Luthra (HUF) (2016) 240 Taxman 133 (Bom); HV Metal ARC (P.) Ltd. v. ACIT (2018) 173 ITD 606 (Delhi - Trib.); Pawan Kumar Singhal v. ACIT (2019) 178 ITD 390 (Delhi - Trib.); DSI-Bridgecon India (P.) Ltd. v. ACIT (2024) 205 ITD 136 (Delhi - Trib.). Figures are illustrative. Educational content only, reflecting the law as of 3 November 2026; check the current law for your facts.

Guides and toolkits

Practice guides at ₹299 each, or ₹699 for all four.

This is an educational publication for professionals. It is not an offer of professional services.

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page