top of page
CA India Logo.png

PGT & ASSOCIATES

Chartered Accountant Firm

Rule 96(10) Now Treated as Gone Since 2017. Is Your IGST Refund Demand Still Alive?

2 days ago
8 min read

For seven years, exporters who bought inputs under Advance Authorisation or EOU exemptions were told their IGST refunds were never due. Many received demands to return them, with 18% interest and penalties.

On 26 October 2026, CBIC conceded the point. The rule behind those demands is now treated as omitted from the day it began.

Quick answer: Circular 264/10/2026-GST, following the Supreme Court in Goodluck India (6 August 2026), says the omission of rule 96(10) is effective from 23 October 2017. Refund denials and recovery demands still pending on 8 October 2024 should fall away; rules 89(4A) and 89(4B) get the same treatment.

Rule 96(10) IGST refund on exports: omission effective from 23 October 2017 under CBIC Circular 264/10/2026-GST

Contents

What did rule 96(10) restrict?

Rule 96 lets an exporter who pays IGST on exported goods get that tax refunded, with the shipping bill treated as the refund application. Rule 96(10), effective from 23 October 2017, carved out a group of exporters who could not use this route.

The bar applied where the exporter had:

  • (a) received supplies on which the supplier used Notification 48/2017-Central Tax (deemed exports, other than capital goods under EPCG), Notification 40/2017-Central Tax (Rate) or 41/2017-Integrated Tax (Rate) (the 0.05% and 0.1% rates for supplies to merchant exporters); or

  • (b) itself imported under Customs Notification 78/2017 (EOUs) or 79/2017 (Advance Authorisation and EPCG) without paying IGST, other than capital goods under EPCG.

An Explanation later clarified that the benefit was not treated as availed where IGST and compensation cess were paid on the inputs and only basic customs duty was exempted.

The policy aim was to stop a double benefit: tax-free inputs plus a cash refund of IGST on exports. Rules 89(4A) and 89(4B) imposed matching limits on exporters who claimed refunds of unutilised input tax credit instead.

What changed: Goodluck India and Circular 264

Notification 20/2024-Central Tax (8 October 2024) omitted rules 96(10), 89(4A) and 89(4B). The GST Council's 54th meeting had found that rule 96(10) was "leading to unnecessary complications without any intended benefit being served", but recommended that the omission be prospective.

The Gujarat High Court, in Addwrap Packaging Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India (13 June 2025), held that the omission applies to every proceeding still pending on 8 October 2024. It quashed the show cause notices and orders-in-original before it and did not need to rule on the validity of rule 96(10).

The Supreme Court (J.B. Pardiwala and K. Vinod Chandran JJ.) dismissed the department's appeals on 6 August 2026 in Goodluck India Ltd. v. Union of India, 2026 INSC 821. Its reasoning:

  • Following Kolhapur Canesugar Works (Constitution Bench, (2000) 2 SCC 536), section 6 of the General Clauses Act does not apply to the omission of a rule

  • Pending proceedings survive an omission only if there is a saving clause or a similar legal device; there was none here, as the ASG fairly conceded

  • The Council's recommendation that the omission be prospective was advisory and does not bind the rule-making authority

  • The rule was dropped to end needless complications, so keeping them alive in pending matters would defeat that purpose

CBIC then issued Circular 264/10/2026-GST on 26 October 2026 under section 168(1). Paragraph 6 says the omission "will be effective retrospectively from 23.10.2017", tells field formations to decide pending rule 96(10) proceedings in line with the judgment, and extends the same treatment to rules 89(4A) and 89(4B).

Four-step test for whether a rule 96(10) IGST refund dispute is covered by Goodluck India and Circular 264/10/2026-GST

Which matters are covered?

The test in both the judgment and the circular is whether the proceeding was pending. In practice, these are covered:

  • IGST refunds withheld or rejected only under rule 96(10), where the claim, an appeal or a writ was still open

  • Show cause notices seeking to recover refunds already paid, with interest and penalty, not yet adjudicated

  • Orders-in-original confirming such demands, where an appeal before the Appellate Authority, GSTAT or a High Court was pending

  • Refunds of unutilised ITC cut down under rule 89(4A) or 89(4B), on the same footing

A dispute is not rescued if the demand also rests on other grounds, such as a mismatch between shipping bills and GSTR-1, or failure to meet the Advance Authorisation conditions. Those grounds must still be answered on the merits.

Worked example: an appeal pending on 8 October 2024

A manufacturer imported raw material under Advance Authorisation without paying IGST (Customs Notification 79/2017), exported finished goods in FY 2018-19 on payment of IGST, and received IGST refunds of ₹1.20 crore.

In 2023 it received a section 74 notice demanding the refund back as erroneous, with interest and an equal penalty. The order-in-original confirmed the demand in March 2024. The company filed an appeal in June 2024 with a 10% pre-deposit of ₹12 lakh. On 8 October 2024 the appeal was pending.

Worked example of rule 96(10) IGST refund demand, interest, penalty and pre-deposit falling away in a pending GST appeal
  • Exposure removed: ₹1.20 crore tax, about ₹1.08 crore interest under section 50 (18% simple for roughly five years) and ₹1.20 crore penalty, about ₹3.48 crore in total

  • Pre-deposit of ₹12 lakh refundable, with interest under section 115 at the section 56 rate of 6% from the date of payment, about ₹1.73 lakh for 2.4 years

  • Action: file a short additional submission citing Goodluck India and Circular 264, and ask for the appeal to be allowed

If the same demand also alleged that some shipping bills did not match GSTR-1, that part would remain open and would need its own reply.

Practice guide for professionals

For drafting replies, appeals and pre-deposit workings in GST disputes, the GST Notices, Demands & Appeals practice guide (₹299) is the closest match to this topic.

Three harder cases

Refund rejected in 2021, no appeal filed

If the rejection order became final long before 8 October 2024, nothing was pending. The judgment and the circular do not address closed matters, so relief here is doubtful unless a remedy is still genuinely open.

Refund repaid under protest after a notice

If the notice or a challenge to it was still pending on 8 October 2024, the payment should be recoverable once the proceeding is decided in your favour. Where the amount was paid voluntarily and no proceeding was open, a fresh refund claim is arguable but contestable, and the two-year limit in section 54 needs careful checking.

New notice issued after October 2024

A notice or order issued now that relies on rule 96(10) for any period from 23 October 2017 runs directly against paragraph 6 of Circular 264. The reply should say so in the first paragraph.

Decision checklist

  • List every rule 96(10), 89(4A) and 89(4B) matter: refund ARNs, shipping bills, SCN and order numbers, appeal numbers

  • Record the status of each on 8 October 2024: pending, under appeal, or final

  • Check whether any ground other than rule 96(10) is raised in the notice or order

  • For pending appeals, file a submission citing Goodluck India (2026 INSC 821) and Circular 264/10/2026-GST

  • For writs in a High Court, seek early listing; the Supreme Court asked High Courts to place these matters before the roster bench

  • After a favourable order, claim the pre-deposit refund in RFD-01 'on account of order' and compute section 115 interest per level

  • Track delayed refunds of IGST itself and claim interest under section 56 where the 60-day period has run

  • Keep Customs-side compliance (export obligation, redemption of the authorisation) separate and up to date

Common mistakes

  • Assuming every old case is reopened: closed matters are not expressly covered

  • Paying a pending demand now to 'settle' it, instead of seeking its withdrawal

  • Ignoring other grounds in the same notice because the rule 96(10) ground has gone

  • Letting an appeal lapse for non-appearance on the view that the issue is settled; the order still has to be passed

  • Forgetting the ITC-refund route: rules 89(4A) and 89(4B) are covered too

  • Treating the ruling as a finding that rule 96(10) was invalid; validity was never decided

Practitioner insights

  • The strongest file is a short one: the order or notice, proof it was pending on 8 October 2024, the judgment and the circular. Long arguments on vires are no longer needed.

  • Where appeals are pending before GSTAT benches, a written request for early disposal on a settled issue usually gets listed faster than a fresh hearing on the merits.

  • Interest is real money here. Compute it per level and per payment date, and include it in the refund claim rather than raising it later.

  • Read the order that disposes of your appeal closely. An order that 'drops' the demand without directing refund still entitles you to the pre-deposit under Circular 259.

For the pre-deposit refund mechanics, see GST appeal pre-deposit under Circular 259. For how intent must now be shown in fraud notices, see Circular 258 and section 74 notices.

Exporters with disputes still open can also use the free GST toolkit.

Provisions at a glance

Provision

What it does

Rule 96(10), CGST Rules

Barred IGST refunds on exports where inputs came under specified exemptions (from 23.10.2017)

Rules 89(4A), 89(4B)

Limited refunds of unutilised ITC on zero-rated supplies in similar cases

Notification 20/2024-CT (8.10.2024)

Omitted rules 96(10), 89(4A) and 89(4B)

Circular 264/10/2026-GST (26.10.2026)

Omission effective from 23.10.2017; pending matters to follow Goodluck India

Section 54, CGST Act

Refund of tax; two-year time limit

Section 56, CGST Act

Interest on delayed refunds (6%; 9% where an order has attained finality)

Sections 107(6), 112(8), 115

Pre-deposit for appeals and interest on its refund

Sections 73, 74 (74A from FY 2024-25)

Demand and recovery of tax, including erroneous refunds

Frequently asked questions

Is rule 96(10) of the CGST Rules omitted retrospectively?

Yes, in effect. Notification 20/2024-Central Tax omitted it from 8 October 2024. After the Supreme Court's 6 August 2026 order in Goodluck India, CBIC Circular 264/10/2026-GST clarifies that the omission is effective retrospectively from 23 October 2017.

Can the department still recover IGST refunds under rule 96(10)?

Not in proceedings that were pending when the rule was omitted. The Supreme Court held that, with no saving clause, the omission applies to all such proceedings, and Circular 264 tells field officers to deal with them in line with that judgment.

Does Circular 264 cover rules 89(4A) and 89(4B)?

Yes. The circular says the same treatment applies, mutatis mutandis, to the omission of rules 89(4A) and 89(4B), which limited refunds of unutilised input tax credit on zero-rated supplies in similar cases.

What if my rule 96(10) case was closed before 8 October 2024?

The judgment and the circular speak of pending proceedings. A refund rejection or demand that became final before that date, with no appeal or writ pending, is not expressly addressed, so relief there is uncertain and depends on whether any remedy is still open in time.

How do I get my pre-deposit back after winning?

File FORM GST RFD-01 under the category 'on account of order'. Circular 259/05/2026-GST says the order need not direct a refund, and the refund cannot be held back only because the department intends to appeal. Interest is due under section 115.

Was the validity of rule 96(10) decided by the Supreme Court?

No. Because the exporters got relief through the omission, their challenges to the vires of rule 96(10) were dismissed as infructuous. The Gujarat High Court had likewise declined to examine validity.

Does this affect Advance Authorisation or EOU conditions under Customs law?

No. The ruling removes a GST refund restriction. Export obligations and other conditions attached to Advance Authorisation, EPCG or EOU benefits under the Customs and foreign trade rules are separate and continue to apply.

Related reading

Sources

CGST Rules, 2017: rules 89(4A), 89(4B), 96(10); Notification 54/2018-Central Tax (substituting rule 96(10)); Notification 20/2024-Central Tax dated 08.10.2024; CBIC Circular 264/10/2026-GST dated 26.10.2026; Circular 259/05/2026-GST dated 26.10.2026; CGST Act, 2017: sections 50, 54, 56, 73, 74, 74A, 107(6), 112(8), 115, 168(1). Goodluck India Ltd. v. Union of India, SLP (C) 24550 of 2025 and connected matters, 2026 INSC 821 (SC, 06.08.2026); Addwrap Packaging Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India, R/SCA 22519 of 2019 and connected matters (Guj. HC, 13.06.2025); Kolhapur Canesugar Works Ltd. v. Union of India (2000) 2 SCC 536. Figures are illustrative. Educational content only, reflecting the law as of 4 November 2026; check the current law for your facts.

Guides and toolkits

Practice guides at ₹299 each, or ₹699 for all four, including GST Notices, Demands & Appeals.

This is an educational publication for professionals. It is not an offer of professional services.

bottom of page