CARO 2020 Clause 3(i): PPE Records, Physical Verification, Title Deeds and Revaluation
Updated: Oct 30
Clause 3(i) is the first reporting clause of the Companies (Auditor's Report) Order, 2020 (CARO 2020). It asks the statutory auditor to report on the company's property, plant and equipment (PPE) and intangible assets: whether records are kept, whether assets are physically verified, whether title deeds of immovable property stand in the company's name, whether assets were revalued, and whether any benami proceedings are pending.
This is part 2 of our clause-by-clause CARO 2020 series. Part 1 covered which companies CARO 2020 applies to for FY 2025-26. This part explains each of the five sub-clauses of 3(i), the evidence an auditor normally collects, and worked examples on title deeds and the 10% revaluation test.

Text and scope of clause 3(i)
Paragraph 3(i) of CARO 2020, notified vide S.O. 849(E) dated 25 February 2020 under Section 143(11) of the Companies Act, 2013, has five sub-clauses. If a company has no PPE or intangible assets at all, the auditor states that the clause is not applicable rather than leaving it out.
Three of the five sub-clauses mirror disclosures that Division I, II and III of Schedule III have required since 1 April 2021 (MCA notification dated 24 March 2021): title deeds not held in the company's name, revaluation based on a registered valuer, and proceedings under benami law. The auditor's reply under CARO and the note in the financial statements should therefore tell the same story.
Clause 3(i)(a): records of PPE and intangible assets
Sub-clause (a)(A) asks whether the company maintains proper records showing full particulars, including quantitative details and situation, of PPE. Sub-clause (a)(B) asks whether proper records showing full particulars of intangible assets are maintained. Quantitative details and location are required only for PPE.
A fixed asset register is the usual record. It should show, for each asset or group of identical assets, a description, identification or tag number, location, quantity, date of acquisition or capitalisation, cost, accumulated depreciation and impairment, and the date of disposal where relevant.
Right-of-use assets under Ind AS 116 are part of PPE for this purpose, so leased premises and vehicles shown as right-of-use assets need to be in the register too.
For intangible assets such as software licences, trademarks and capitalised development costs, the register should carry particulars such as the nature of the right, registration or licence details, cost, useful life and amortisation.
Check that the register totals agree with the general ledger and the PPE note. A register that is not reconciled to the books is not a proper record.
Practice guide for professionals
For working-paper formats and review checklists on this topic, see the Audit Documentation & CARO 2020 Practical Guide (PDF, ₹299).
Clause 3(i)(b): physical verification by management
The auditor reports whether PPE has been physically verified by management at reasonable intervals, whether any material discrepancies were noticed, and, if so, whether they were properly dealt with in the books of account. Physical verification is management's job; the auditor reviews the programme and its results.
Reasonable interval depends on the nature and number of assets. The ICAI Guidance Note on CARO 2020 accepts a phased programme under which all assets are covered over a period, commonly up to three years, provided the programme is reasonable for the size of the company.
Ask for the verification programme, the signed verification sheets, and the reconciliation of the count with the fixed asset register.
Discrepancies are judged against the size of the PPE base. Material shortfalls must be written off or adjusted, and the reason recorded.
Intangible assets cannot be physically counted, so (b) is about PPE only.
Example 1: verification discrepancy
Delta Engineering Pvt Ltd has PPE with a net carrying value of ₹8 crore. Under a three-year programme approved by the board, plant at its Sanand unit was counted in March 2026. Two machines with a net carrying value of ₹3.2 lakh could not be traced; they had been scrapped in 2023 but never removed from the register.
The discrepancy is 0.4% of PPE, so it is not material on its own, but it shows the register was not updated for disposals.
The company wrote off ₹3.2 lakh in FY 2025-26 and updated the register. Since the discrepancy was dealt with in the books, the auditor can report under (b) that no material discrepancies were noticed, while recording the facts and the reconciliation in the working papers.
If the missing assets had been material and not adjusted, the reply under (b) would be qualified, and the auditor would also consider the effect on the main audit opinion.
Clause 3(i)(c): title deeds of immovable property
The auditor reports whether the title deeds of all immovable properties disclosed in the financial statements are held in the name of the company. Properties where the company is the lessee and the lease agreements are duly executed in its favour are excluded. Where title is not in the company's name, details must be given in a six-column format:
Description of property
Gross carrying value
Held in the name of
Whether the holder is a promoter, director, their relative or an employee
Period held (a range may be given)
Reason for not being held in the name of the company, and whether it is in dispute
The clause speaks of immovable properties disclosed in the financial statements, so look beyond the PPE note: investment property and land or buildings held for sale are also disclosed in the financial statements.
Inspect the original registered sale deed or conveyance. Where deeds are deposited with a bank as security, obtain a confirmation from the bank and match the property description.
A property still in the name of the erstwhile firm or the amalgamating company after a conversion or merger is not held in the company's name until the records are updated, and has to be reported with the reason.
Example 2: reporting a property in a director's name
Epsilon Textiles Pvt Ltd shows three immovable properties: a factory on freehold land registered in the company's name; an office taken on a registered 9-year lease; and a godown bought in June 2019 for ₹1.20 crore and registered in the name of a director, Mr A, because a bank loan was taken in his name at the time.
Factory: title in the company's name. Nothing to report.
Office: the company is a lessee under a duly executed lease, so it is outside 3(i)(c).
Godown: report in the table as Godown at [location]; gross carrying value ₹1.20 crore; held in the name of Mr A; director; held since June 2019; reason: registered in the director's name for loan purposes, transfer to the company pending, not in dispute.
The same details should appear in the Schedule III note on title deeds not held in the company's name. The auditor should also consider whether the arrangement raises questions under Section 185 or Section 188 of the Companies Act, 2013.
Clause 3(i)(d): revaluation of PPE and intangible assets
The auditor reports whether the company revalued its PPE (including right-of-use assets) or intangible assets, or both, during the year, and if so, whether the revaluation is based on the valuation by a registered valuer. Where the change is 10% or more of the aggregate net carrying value of a class of PPE or intangible assets, the amount of change must be specified.
Revaluation is permitted under the revaluation model in Ind AS 16 and Ind AS 38, and under AS 10 for companies following Indian GAAP.
Registered valuer has the meaning in the Companies (Registered Valuers and Valuation) Rules, 2017. A valuation by an engineer or a bank's empanelled valuer who is not registered with IBBI does not meet this condition, and the reply must say so.
The 10% test is applied class by class on the net carrying value, not to total PPE.
For the Section 247 framework and a checklist on engaging a registered valuer, see Companies Act Valuation 2026: Section 247 and Registered Valuer Checklist.
Example 3: applying the 10% test
Zeta Foods Ltd follows the Ind AS 16 revaluation model and revalued two classes on 31 March 2026, using a valuer registered with IBBI for land and buildings.
Freehold land: net carrying value ₹4.00 crore, revalued to ₹4.60 crore. Change ₹0.60 crore, which is 15%. Report that the revaluation is by a registered valuer and state the amount of change, ₹0.60 crore.
Buildings: net carrying value ₹10.00 crore, revalued to ₹10.50 crore. Change ₹0.50 crore, which is 5%. Report that the revaluation is by a registered valuer; the amount need not be specified because it is below 10%.

Clause 3(i)(e): benami property proceedings
The auditor reports whether any proceedings have been initiated or are pending against the company for holding benami property under the Benami Transactions (Prohibition) Act, 1988 (now titled the Prohibition of Benami Property Transactions Act, 1988) and the rules under it, and if so, whether the company has appropriately disclosed the details in its financial statements.
Evidence usually consists of a management representation, a review of notices from the Initiating Officer or Adjudicating Authority, and inquiry of the company's legal team.
The clause covers proceedings against the company as holder of benami property. It does not ask the auditor to decide whether any transaction is benami.
If proceedings exist, compare the Schedule III disclosure (details of property, year and amount, beneficiaries, and status of proceedings) with the notices.
Audit checklist for clause 3(i)
Obtain the fixed asset register and intangible asset register and reconcile them with the trial balance and the PPE and intangibles notes.
Review the physical verification programme, the latest count sheets and the treatment of discrepancies.
List every immovable property disclosed in the financial statements, inspect title deeds or bank confirmations, and prepare the six-column table for exceptions.
For revaluations, obtain the valuation report, verify the valuer's IBBI registration, and compute the change class by class.
Obtain a written representation on benami proceedings and review legal notices.
Agree each CARO reply to the matching Schedule III disclosure and document the conclusion in line with SA 230.
Where the company is also subject to tax audit, depreciation and asset additions also feed into Form 3CD; see Form 3CA vs 3CB vs 3CD for AY 2026-27.
Related reading
Sources: CARO 2020, paragraph 3(i) (S.O. 849(E) dated 25 February 2020, as amended); Section 143(11) and Schedule III of the Companies Act, 2013 (as amended by MCA notification dated 24 March 2021); Companies (Registered Valuers and Valuation) Rules, 2017; Prohibition of Benami Property Transactions Act, 1988; ICAI Guidance Note on CARO 2020. Company names in the examples are illustrative.




Comments